Basement Songs: “For Good,” from “Wicked”

Last year our house was overrun by witches.  You’d think that in the 21st Century there would be some kind of way to control witch infestation, but there was no stopping these mystical creatures from getting into our home.  Let me explain.

In the winter of 2007, Julie and Sophie went to see the phenomenon known as Wicked. Seeing the Los Angeles production of the Tony Award-winning musical by Stephen Schwartz was so magical that the experience was relived day after day for nearly a year.  The original cast recording, featuring Idina Menzel as Elphaba, the green-skinned, misunderstood future wicked witch of the west, and Kristin Chenoweth as Galinda, soon to be Glinda the good witch, was played endlessly.  For the first time, I saw in Julie the kind of obsession some people display for artists like, I don’t know, Springsteen, and Sophie could be heard singing the music nearly every day for a year until she’d memorized every line and was able to recreate scenes from memory.

The snippets of music I paid attention to were very melodic and I enjoyed them.  But, honestly, I didn’t understand what the big deal was.  As I didn’t read the CD booklet or do any research on Wicked, I only knew the basics:  It’s a rite-of-passage tale of how two young women, complete opposites, form a loving friendship and how they eventually become the (in)famous  characters from L. Frank Baum’s classic, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. The play, based on Gregory Maguire’s book, Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West, has become a sensation of Titanic proportions.

As 2008 drew to a close, Julie and Sophie desperately wanted to see Wicked again since the L.A. production was set to close in mid-January ‘09.  Adding to their enthusiasm was the news that actresses Eden Espinosa and Megan Hilty, whom they’d seen as the leads in ’07, would be returning to reprise their roles of Elphaba and Glinda, respectively. They both insisted that Jacob and I had to see it to fully comprehend its greatness.  So, in lieu of a birthday party this year. Sophie asked if we could go see Wicked and in mid-December, just before Christmas, our family drove into downtown Los Angeles to the historic Pantages Theater for a night on Broadway.

We took our seats: Julie and I next to each other, Jacob sitting to my right, Sophie to Julie’s left.  The lights dimmed and the orchestra began.  Jacob gripped my hand as the curtain raised and the overture started.  Instantly we were transported to the land of Oz, thanks to Winnie Holzman’s sensitive script and the winning songs from Stephen Schwartz.  Periodically I looked over at him, curious if he was getting scared.  Instead, I saw my little boy sitting wide-eyed and in awe at the wondrous things happening on stage while glorious melodies were performed.   As the curtain dropped after the spectacular Act I ending “Defying Gravity” (in which actress Espinosa was hoisted into the air – flying – and beams of light burst out behind her) I was thrilled that we had come to the play.

Throughout my entire childhood my parents hauled us to musicals.  Not just the big shows that came through the Cleveland downtown theaters, but many local productions that were just as good as (and sometimes superior to) the Broadway touring productions.  Sitting in the Pantages, watching Wicked, I was reminded how much I love live theater, how much I do love musicals, and how much I miss the opportunity to see them.  I was so glad that Sophie and Jake were at least being exposed to something as beautiful and moving as Wicked.  I was also glad that I was able to sit there with my son and observe how much he was enjoying it.  Someday he may recall that night with fondness and I’m glad that I was a part of it.

For the second act, we changed seats and I sat next to Sophie.  Because she was the Wicked veteran, I figured I would be able to just focus on the stage, not having to worry about whether the flying monkeys were too intense for her.  As Act II unfolded, I was continually surprised by the many twists and the clever ways the play tied into the whole mythology of L. Frank Baum’s original book (as well as the landmark film).  Moreover, it impressed me with its themes of tolerance, empowerment, acceptance, and most importantly, forgiveness.  During several of the high drama moments, I couldn’t resist seeing how Sophie was reacting.  Looking at her, I was often more touched at her connection to the play than what was on stage.  With her eyes lasered in on the action, as if memorizing every gesture of the actresses, Sophie quietly sang along with each and every song, never looking away, never letting go of my hand.

The final duet between Glinda and Elphaba is a moving number entitled “For Good,” which these two women, once hated roommates and now best friends, must say goodbye for the last time.  In the song, the two admit that their lives are better for knowing each other and that they will never be the same.  Out of context from the musical, “For Good” is a beautiful ballad that has universal appeal.  Someday I can hear Sophie singing this at her high school graduation and hitting each note sincerely, a heartfelt dedication to her own friends.  As this grand number crescendos into the final chorus, it was the father squeezing his child’s hand tighter, and the child looking over to see her father fighting back tears, overwhelmed with joy.  In that moment I understood.  I understood why this play has been so successful and connects with people emotionally; I understood why Julie and Sophie had effused over it for a year; and I understood what it was like for all of the people I had dragged to Springsteen shows for the first time and said, “I get it.”
I thanked God that I was able to be there, in this moment, experiencing the same emotions as my daughter.

After the show had ended and the applause had faded away, as we joined the massive crowd making its way back to their cars in the chilly December air, the poignant melody of “For Good” sang on in my mind and my heart ached.  Our time in Oz had been short and, well, quite wonderful.  I was going to miss those characters and what we’d been through together.  A play, very much like a concert, is a unique experience between the performers and the audience.  No two nights are the same, no matter how rehearsed the production.  I may see Wicked again someday (I know I’ll see the film when it eventually gets made), but it will not be the same.  Still, whenever I hear Sophie’s voice singing through the house, I’ll be reminded of the gift she gave me.  Going to see Wicked may have been a birthday present to her, but Sophie gave me a memory that I will cherish forever, a memory that has changed me for good.

Tags: , ,

  • Gary Lucy
    Not to overstate the case, but "Wicked" is maybe the most profound piece of pop culture in the last 10 years or so... REALLY great. I'm sure Chenowyth & Mendel killed it on Broadway, but I only ever saw the LA one and those gals were just amazing. The Schwartz tunes are terrific, but let's also give props to Winnie "My So Called Life" Holzman for the tremendous book & some of the lyrics.
  • Malchus
    Did Holzman write some of the lyrics? That's amazing. She did fantastic work paring down the book to what wound up on stage.
  • Dan
    Soctt, as I am typing this, several tears are slowly sliding down my cheeks. You did indeed "get it." Beyond the joy and wonderment of seeing the show through your daughter's eyes, you also were able to see it through your own while envisioning sights yet to come. With your permission, I plan to save this entry and share it with my students during the times they forget how magical the theater experience is. You did indeed "get it," and may you, Julie, Jacob and Sophie cherish that gift for life!
  • JonCummings
    Scott, your experience was much like mine--though, actually, mine was probably more like Julie's, because I got to see Wicked twice in LA. The first time Gwen and I took Jacob, who was 10 and had seen a truncated and expurgated "production" of the show at this elementary school the previous spring (more about that later). He had loved the music when he heard it at school, but had decided to be unenthusiastic about seeing the actual show because (like most 10-year-old boys) he felt he was too cool for a dorky musical. Of course, as soon as we got into the theater and he saw that dragon's head above the proscenium he was hooked, and he wound up being completely entranced by the show. It was wonderful watching his too-cool-for-school exoskeleton dissolve for a while as he allowed himself to respond to the magic and emotion in the performance.

    My second viewing came last summer, when 6-year-old Catie and I saw the show on a "date" while Gwen and Jacob were away. She's rarely been more excited in her life, and she spent the show with her mouth wide open in wonder. When I asked her afterward whether she was a popular Glinda or a daring Elphaba, she said, "I kinda think I want to be both!" It was a good answer.

    As for that school production--our school district's music supervisor launched student productions of Wicked (actually, only the non-dramatic parts of the first act plus a couple songs from the second, including "For Good") in every elementary school...but not under the name "Wicked." Instead--worried about the conservative Christians who might get offended by a play with that title--the productions were titled "The Untold Story of Oz."

    Having already gone ballistic on several occasions over the Christians' attempts to change our school's mascot -- a wizard -- I completely blew a nut over the "Wicked" business. I scheduled a meeting with the school's (very conservative) principal, who insisted she had no control over what had been done to the play. I wrote a letter to the district questioning whether they had secured a legal right to present a truncated show under a different name, which was never answered. It required a lot of restraint, particularly considering my anti-censorship obsessiveness, to resist picking up the phone and calling the ACLU on my kids' school.

    It's unfortunate that such concerns should in any way sully a terrific show like Wicked, whose message is one every kid (and some of their parents, especially around where I live) should take to heart.
  • It's a shame that fundamentalists have that much pull on your school since Wicked actually has a lot more to say than just "ooga booga, Dungeons and Dragons!"
  • Eric S.
    I've had a similar "Wicked" experience. I went with my wife and daughters the first time knowing only that is was loosely an invented back-story to "The Wizard of Oz". I had low expectations going in, but the music and performances blew me away. It wasn't hard for my girls to convince me to buy the soundtrack for them. Since that first time, my younger daughter has gotten into musical theater in a big way (Kristen Chenoweth is her idol). We've since seen the show in Chicago and again in Detroit. While I enjoy the show, it is definitely something more than that for the women. Beyond the sisterhood elements, it's not something I can readily explain as a male. I do owe a debt of gratitude to the women in my family for introducing me to things like this and the equally enjoyable "Rent".
  • Bike Kinzle
    Awwwwwww. Takes me back to when I wassa mere Tot , and my folks took me to see Man a la Mancha downtown. Peter O'Toole and Sophia Loren were the main liners if memory serves me correctly. Wide eyed n bushy tailed. Good times. To dream the impossible dream. :)
  • Great piece, Scott! I just might have to go see Wicked now, of course with my daughter!
blog comments powered by Disqus