Five Band Members No One Bothered to Replace

Jeff Giles November 2, 2011 21

These are uncertain times for America’s workforce, what with high unemployment, massive seasonal layoffs, and gutted/broke/busted pension plans wherever you look. And you know who understands all that financial turmoil better than you might think? Our great nation’s hardworking pop stars.

It’s true! They might get to play under the spotlights for thousands of screaming fans, but all that fame and adulation comes with a price: the knowledge that at any moment, they could lose their fancy gig and end up giving drum lessons on Thursday nights in the back room of a strip mall instrument shop. And just like that time your entire department was downsized with three days’ notice because the CEO needed to make sure he made his annual bonus, sometimes band members aren’t even replaced. Check out these examples:

38 Special

Which one is Steve? Maybe none of them.

Steve Brookins, 38 Special
Of all the rock bands who decided to add a second drummer in the ’70s, none needed one less than 38 Special. Where the Allmans and the Doobies used the extra skins to add a layer of boogie to their rock, 38 used their four percussion arms to…handle all those tricky fills in “Caught Up in You” and “Hold on Loosely”? Yeah, probably not. Brookins vanished after 1986′s Safety in Numbers, with fellow founding drummer Jack Grondin out the door after 1991′s Bone Against Steel.

"I quit."

Steve Porcaro, Toto
How many keyboard players does it take to play “Rosanna”? Two, believe it or not. One of three Porcaros who served time in Toto, the synth-toting Steve stuck around for the band’s first six albums, leaving after 1986′s Isolation when he realized he’d co-written Michael Jackson’s “Human Nature” and never needed to work another day in his life.

"Sod off."

Peter Gabriel and Steve Hackett, Genesis
Unlike most of the other names on this list, Peter Gabriel and Steve Hackett (our third Steve. Hmmm) made a pretty big splash when they gave up their gigs. Gabriel, of course, was the walking flower pot who sang lead vocals on Genesis’ first six studio albums, while Hackett was the innovative guitarist who helped solidify what’s generally regarded as their classic lineup. No matter — when Gabriel took a hike after The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, they just tossed the mic to drummer Phil Collins, and when Hackett followed suit a couple of years later, bassist Mike Rutherford shrugged and added “lead guitar” to his job description. Beer commercials followed.

"Just a few more inches and I'll have my hands around Cronin's neck."

Jesse Harms, REO Speedwagon
Picture it: It’s the late ’80s, and you’re an in-demand session player who just wrote Eddie Money’s Top 10 hit “Walk on Water.” The corporate rock world is your oyster! What do you do? For Jesse Harms, the answer was “join REO Speedwagon and co-write the bulk of one of the most oddly titled flop albums in history.” Never mind that the band already had a keyboard player — founding member Neal Doughty, who wasn’t going anywhere — or that most of REO’s remaining fans had too much dignity or self-respect to walk up to a store clerk holding a copy of something called The Earth, a Small Man, His Dog and a Chicken. The band went on a six-year recording break, and Harms went on to join Sammy Hagar’s Waboritas. Call it a draw.

  • http://twitter.com/SockOfFleagulls Jason Gross

    Holy crap this is a good article!

  • http://twitter.com/SockOfFleagulls Jason Gross

    Holy crap this is a good article. Nicely done!!!

  • http://www.grayflannelsuit.net/ Chris Holmes

    I am one of the relatively few Genesis diehards who would only shell out to see a reunion concert with Hackett in tow.

  • David_E

    Let the record show, at least, that Steve Porcaro was a great keyboardist, a fine songwriter and even a pleasant (if Mellow Goldy) singer. I never liked Toto as much after his departure. Not sure why.

  • jack

    Great idea for an article! Now I’m going to spend the rest of the day with 30% of my brain trying to think of other examples.

    So far all I have is Kajagoogoo dumping Limahl and becoming Kaja with the bass player singing.

    Oh, how about when Stu Sutcliffe left his band and one of their three(!) guitarists switched to bass? And that’s how he became Paul McCartney, bassist for the Beatles.

  • http://mostlymodernmedia.wordpress.com Beau

    Jamie Muir, King Crimson.

  • David_E

    Alan “Fitz” Gerald.

    #HowCouldYouMissThis

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Some of us DID miss “Fitz.” Harumph.

  • Dan Wiencek

    And then there’s Roger Waters.

  • jack

    “Hello, what am I, chopped liver?” –Guy Pratt
     
    (bassist for Pink Floyd [on tours, at least] and son-in-law of Rick Wright)

  • http://sonicweapons.net Thierry

    Chris Bell, Big Star. 

  • Dan Wiencek

    Not to say they didn’t get a new bass player, but they did NOT get a new conceptualist/writer/vocalist who contributed to the band on equal terms with Gilmour, Mason and Wright.

  • jack

    Fair enough! I’m glad they didn’t pull a “Queen and Paul Rodgers.” Who COULD have replaced Roger Waters?

  • David

    Trying to add some more off the top of my head . . .

    Creedence Clearwater Revival continued as a three-piece for 1-2 albums after Tom Fogerty left.

    Strangely, after Jim Morrison died, the Doors continued as a three-piece for 2 more albums that everyone has forgotten (1971′s Other Voices and 1972′s Full Circle), with Manzarek, Krieger, and Densmore splitting the vocals and songwriting amongst them.

    Joy Division sans the deceased Ian Curtis transformed into New Order (not sure if that counts given the name change).

  • http://somethingelsereviews.com/ Pico

    Skunk Baxter, Jim Hodder, Denny Dias and David Palmer–Steely Dan (ok, so they were replaced by a vast array of for-hire studio musicians, but still…)

  • http://somethingelsereviews.com/ Pico

    Steve P. continued to contribute synths to Toto albums all the way up through their last album Falling In Between. Greg Phillinganes eventually became his official replacement as second keyboardist.

  • Old_Davy

    Anyone besides Colin and Andy in XTC.

  • David_E

    Yep. But his presence was less and less felt, his songwriting nonexistent, and their move to Rawk more and more pronounced. It was probably just the changing times, or coincidence, but … I still never liked their albums Post-Steve as much as those with him.

  • http://somethingelsereviews.com/ Pico

    Oh I agree, he became merely a sideman at that point and that might have had an impact on the direction the band went afterwards. My remarks were more directed at the notion in the main article that he totally left the band and they never replaced him. That’s not entirely true.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    I know what you’re saying is technically accurate, but he wasn’t an “official” member after he left — and by the time Phillinganes came aboard, I’d argue he was just as much a replacement for the dwindling Paich.

  • Waylan

    That’s a good one. After Dave Gregory was out they were a duo, and then after Wasp Star they were, sadly, over. There was also awesomely ham-fisted drummer Terry Chambers who went unreplaced after he left during the recording of Mummer.