UXDE dot Net

Fixing a Hole: The Beatles’ Imaginary Post-1970 Albums, Part 11

By -

Part 11: Help Yourself (1993)

I went through more iterations of this album than any other one in this series, but finally think I’ve got it as good as it’s going to get.  Some people may disagree with this hypothetical turn of events, but I think with the Beatles on top of the world again after Fab, combined with a vastly changing musical landscape, combined with the early ‘90s trend of cramming as much music onto a CD as humanly possible, this would’ve resulted in prime conditions for the Fab Four to get ambitious again.

So if Fab is the late Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper, Help Yourself (named after Julian’s 1991 release) is the late Beatles’ White Album.  For the few and proud who were sticking with vinyl, this was a double album, so I will present it as four sides below.  But for everyone else, this was a single CD, jam-packed with 18 songs and 77 minutes of music.  Like the White Album, it would be lambasted upon initial release as being self-indulgent, excessive, and reviewed with comments such as “there’s a good album hiding in there somewhere.”  But I think also like the White Album, that’s part of its charm; it’s an album that grows on you, moves the Beatles in some very unconventional directions, even for them, it’s darker than its predecessor much like the early ‘90s were darker than the late ‘80s, and challenges the listener, much more so than the more straightforward Fab did.

I can just hear Paul responding to the less-than-positive reviews in an interview by saying “Well, the album is called Help Yourself, and it’s a bloody CD, innit?  So you can just bloody well Help Yourself and press the bloody skip button past the songs you don’t like if you bloody want to!”  Ultimately I’ll admit it’s not as good as Fab, but it’s not as bad as it might appear just by examining the track list.  Give it time.

And once again, it seems that several Julian songs do not have YouTube uploads.  So I’ve taken things into my own hands and uploaded them here.  The albums are long out of print, so hopefully I’m not breaking any rules.

SIDE ONE

Peace In the Neighborhood” – Double albums often begin with something fairly safe and bland to set the stage, so I thought this would be a good choice.  Catchy tune from Paul’s Off the Ground album (more on that later), but does suffer from some pretty lazy lyrics like “there really was something there.”

Saltwater” – Julian’s Help Yourself album, like Mr. Jordan, is about half gems, half throwaways in my opinion, so I’ve often thought about putting together an album called Help Yourself, Mr. Jordan that would be absolutely KILLER.  This is one of the few Julian songs, musically and lyrically, that I think John Lennon could’ve written himself; admist its tearful save-the-planet message, it’s got John’s dark edge (and a not-so-subtle musical nod to “Strawberry Fields Forever” at the beginning).  If this had been on Valotte it would’ve been a huge hit.

Weight of the World” – One of Ringo’s greatest singles ever, and the dawn of the era where his music gets surprisingly high-quality and one can even call him a decent singer.

Someplace Else” – A sweeping ballad from Cloud Nine that recalls George’s late ‘70s work in many ways, so I thought it made more sense here than on Fab.  That, and we have to stretch the Cloud Nine material out to cover multiple albums.

SIDE TWO

Open Your Eyes” – leftover from Mr. Jordan, but too weird for inclusion on Fab.  It’s a good setting-the-stage song that I think would’ve been a little shorter in this context.  No YouTube link, strangely.  But if you can’t find it, the album doesn’t lose a whole lot without it.

Hope of Deliverance” – I remember hearing this on the radio when it was new and being highly unimpressed that this was the best Paul could come with after four years off since Flowers in the Dirt.  I finally bought Off the Ground a year later when it reached the cut-out bins and was largely unimpressed.  But since then, both the leadoff single and the album as a whole have grown on me.  This is a much more complex song than it would initially seem, given its bouncy nature.  And Off the Ground is no Flowers, but no McCartney collection would be complete without it.  HOWEVER, it would’ve been even better if some slightly different choices about what got included had been made.  More on that later.

Poor Little Girl” – George should really have written more edgy songs, he’s very good at them.  There’s a strong Roy Orbison influence here too, undoubtedly picked up from his Wilbury days.

Biker Like An Icon” – I stood by “Girlfriend,” I stood by “So Bad,” and I’m going to stand by this one too.  Yes, the lyrics are kind of silly, but are than any siller than “Penny Lane” or “Ob-La-Di-Ob-La-Da”?  Not really.  And the chorus just sticks in your head like you wouldn’t believe.

Take Me Home” – Record one ends with a pretty Lennon ballad, just like record one of the White Album did.  Not that I’m equating the two, I just thought it would be cute to do it this way.

SIDE THREE

Big Boys Bickering” – Off the Ground song selection follies, Exhibit I.  What was the problem here?  Was it the F-bomb (Very well-placed, I might add) and Paul’s desire to avoid a ‘parental advisory’ sticker?  Did he not want to upset a bunch of stodgy old politicians?  The Beatles would’ve sung this and been proud.  After all, it was the grunge era, they had to throw some angst on here, right?

Listen” – A powerful, albeit more vague rocker from Julian to continue what I think is the Beatles’ darkest side of music perhaps since “Rubber Soul.”

Devil’s Radio” – With “Ebony and Ivory,” “Tears Of the World,” and now this song, the Beatles in the ‘80s and ‘90s were finally speaking their mind about specific topics (as opposed to more general message songs like “Imagine,” “All You Need Is Love” or “Revolution”), which I think makes sense.

Don’t Go Where the Road Don’t Go” – It’s easy to dismiss this song from Ringo’s excellent Time Takes Time album as just another attempt at quaint silliness, but I think it’s actually got an ironic questioning-of-authority undertone.

Help Yourself” – Allow me to get personal for a brief moment: I can not put in words completely how inspirational I think this song is, and how much it helped me through a very difficult freshman year of college.  Unlike “Saltwater,” this is pure Julian, without a whole lot of traditional Beatle influences, and yet I also think it’s a song that his father would’ve been supremely proud of him for writing had he lived to hear it.  And it closes out this dark and challenging side of vinyl with a glimmer of hope.  And some well-placed studio chatter at the end to relieve the tension.

SIDE FOUR

Kicked Around No More” – Off the Ground song selection follies, Exhibit II.  How on earth did this gorgeous, hypnotic song get left off of Off the Ground in favor of bland rockers like “Looking For Changes” and post-hippie pap like “Golden Earth Girl?”  I hope Paul isn’t reading this.  I still love you, man.

Breath Away From Heaven” – The pseudo-Eastern synth sounds may have been a bit dated by this point, but I thought it fit well in the musical context of the songs before and after, and I had to have at least one Harrison tune here that escaped the Jeff Lynne production monster (admittedly, it probably only escaped it because of the lack of drums).  The transition into the next song is surprisingly seamless.

Keep The People Working” – So, so different from anything the Beatles, John, or even Julian ever recorded, but the Beatles were always about taking some risks.  And it still rocks.  On the real Help Yourself it’s the last song, but I like it better as a penultimate song, because of…

C’Mon People” – No reason why this couldn’t have been a smash hit with the Beatles’ brand name attached to it.  Paul has at least one longish, amibitious song on most of his albums in the past 20 years, but this one is still my favorite, and one of the few times in his solo career when Paul thinks he has another epic on his hands and he really does.  It’s one of those songs that you swear you’ve heard before the first time you hear it, which means it instantly sticks with you.  What a great video too.  Would they have included the “Cosmically Conscious” section at the end (which isn’t on this version) as a hidden bonus track?  I go back and forth on that, but if you don’t think so, you can just press the bloody stop button.

SINGLES

Hope Of Deliverance b/w Would You, #20, 1993

Saltwater b/w Mistress and Maid, #2, 1993 (kept out of the #1 spot by the Four Non Blondes’ “What’s Up,” much to the disgust of Beatle fans across America)

C’Mon People, #1, 1993

Devil’s Radio, b/w Off the Ground, #8, 1994

WELL-KNOWN SONGS THAT DIDN’T MAKE THE CUT

Are there any?  Don’t think so, and I doubt there will be much more of those as we move forward.

SPECIAL SECTION: HELP YOURSELF “LITE”

Undoubtedly, there will be those of you who are saying “well gee, if you think the reception for this album would’ve been ‘there’s a good album hidden in there somewhere’, why not just make that good album?”  And of course I’ve asked myself that very same question.  So on days when one is less in the mood for excess, here’s the slightly-different-parallel-future version of Help Yourself where the Beatles stopped the presses at the last minute and said “let’s exercise some restraint and make this a single LP.”

SIDE ONE:

Hope Of Deliverance / Weight of the World / Big Boys Bickering / Saltwater / Devil’s Radio / Help Yourself

SIDE TWO:

Biker Like An Icon / Poor Little Girl / Listen / Kicked Around No More / Keep the People Working / C’mon People

Next time… more mellowness and maturity.

Enhanced by Zemanta
  • Anonymous

    For what it’s worth, I honestly think Julian’s Help Yourself was one of the best pop albums, if not albums period, of the 1990′s. And for the first time, I think, since you started this series I absolutely agree with you about the positive, uplifting effect of the title song. I perhaps would have placed the nutball (and clever) “New Physics Rant” on there instead of “Keep the People Working”, but that’s just me.

    Also, on the subject of Off the Ground, I too have come to like it more and more as the years have gone by, but one track I liked from the beginning was the low-key, somewhat funky title cut. Great harmonies on the chorus really help, and I remember hearing it on the radio before I bought the record (after “Hope of Deliverance” had its run- that one still underwhelms me a bit), and hoping it would be a hit.

  • http://twitter.com/MattSpringer Matt Springer

    Fantastic work as always! I’m comfortable with “Biker Like An Icon” being a 1990s “Rocky Raccoon.”

  • Anonymous

    Couldn’t agree with you more on those two Off The Ground b-sides, especially “Kicked Around No More,” which is among my all-time favorite McCartney songs.

  • Brendan

    Nice track list for the “Lite Album”. “Back On My Feet” didn’t make the cut? Maybe that was a b-side that I missed on one of your singles. I do have to say that in the grunge infested waters of 1993, I do not see a song like “C’Mon People” cracking the Top 20, let alone reaching #1. Fairly MOR effort by Sir Paul. Sorry to not see more from Ringo’s best effort in 20 years (thanks to the Jellyfish guys).

  • mark

    Well, grunge was big in 1993, but it was far from dominant, in the same way that disco was big in the late ’70s, but if one were to take a Top 40 cross section at any point in say 1978, probably only 25% or so of the songs would actually be disco songs. And it’s the Beatles after all, so I still say it’s possible.

    I think I listed “Back On My Feet” as a B-side last time around. I do like it, just not quite enough for it make it onto an album. I also included “I Don’t Believe You” on the last album since Ringo didn’t have anything to choose from in the late ’80s.

  • http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_songs-Power-Pop.html Brett Alan

    It’s funny…every McCartney fan agrees that Paul makes poor choices about what to feature as a single, what to put on albums, and what to relegate to B-sides. That is, they agree *until* they start discussing specifics.

    When I saw your first reference to what was left off Off The Ground, I was totally with you. “Yeah”, I thought,” get ‘I Can’t Imagine’ in there, it’s such a great song!” But “Kicked Around No More”–to me that’s one of his absolute worst moments, a limp re-write of “Once Upon A Long Ago”, which I didn’t think much of to begin with. Not saying I’m right and you’re wrong–just saying that you get a LOT of that in Paul fandom.

    I’m a big fan of Off The Ground, and yes, I like “Biker Like An Icon”, enough that the “Biker Like An Icon” shirt from the 1993 tour is one of the few shirts I’ve ever paid official-concert price for. My favorites from it, though, are “Get Out Of My Way”, “Looking For Changes”, and “Winedark Open Sea”. Oh, well. And I also greatly miss “After All These Years”, which is my favorite song of Ringo’s, probably ever.

    Appreciate you posting the Julian tracks. Had the album back when, but it’s been quite a while since I’ve heard that stuff. Looking forward to it.

  • James B

    Mark, now that we’re firmly in the 1990s, are you planning on including Sean Lennon in the fun? His 1998 release “Into the Sun” has a number of worthy contenders for inclusion.

  • James B

    As for the Help Yourself album, I love that you have C’mon People ending it. It’s one of Paul’s best songs that no one knows. The first time I heard it was at the New World Tour in 1994 and it blew me away. It ranks up there with Hey Jude, Maybe I’m Amazed and Let It Be as one of McCartney’s best anthems.

  • Tim

    Is there a reason C’mon People doesn’t have a B-Side?

    I also am not a fan of the Keep the People Working. I don’t think it sounds at all like something the Beatles would do. I also don’t dig the non-Beatle composing credits. I don’t mind the song…it just doesn’t fit…especially with the composing credits falling to someone other than Lennon/McCartney/Harrison/Starr.

  • Tim

    Also, I got bored tonight and used Garage Band to create Part 4′s live album. I didn’t have space for the encores, so it stops at I Want You, but it fits one CD. The plan for some weekend is to split it at some point and add the four encores as prescribed in Part 4. I had to be creative with a few since they didn’t have Live version. I also tried to be a little creative with transitions…didn’t always work great…but it’s something.

  • mark

    Just when I thought I had this album all figured out, y’all go and suggest other songs that turned out to be really good when I revisited them today. So there some alternate possibilities below…

    C’Mon People doesn’t have a B-side because… I screwed up. I think After All These Years would make a fine B side there. That was a very tough omission – it could take the place of Don’t Go Where The Road Don’t Go (perhaps with some resequencing, because I think After All These Years would make a great second-to-last song), but I like ‘em both. Just too many choices from Time Takes Time, a very solid album that blew me away at the time it was released (partly because I wasn’t expecting much, but partly because it really is good).

    I’m tempted to suggest replacing Breath Away From Heaven with After All These Years, and then switching it with Keep the People Working so that it can be second to last. Of course that would mean George and Ringo would each have three songs, as opposed to four and two, but what the hey.

    Don’t know why Sean Lennon never occurred to me. I’ve actually never heard his albums (he appears to have recorded another album in 2006), but I’ll see if I can give them a listen sometime soon (and revise the next entry before its release date). His voice doesn’t come nearly as close to John’s as Julian’s does, so it would be more of a stretch if one was going with the “pretend Julian’s songs are actually John’s” mindframe.

    Glad there’s another “Kicked Around No More” fan out there. And yes, it’s true, Paul fans seem to diverge greatly as to what their favorite songs are, probably because he can do so many different styles so well. I think the only thing it really has in common with “Once Upon A Long Ago” is that the tempo is similar. It’s a much better song IMHO.

    @Brett Alan – I also revisited “I Can’t Imagine” and I agree with you on that one! Why didn’t I notice it before? Who knows. You know, it wouldn’t make a bad leadoff track in place of “Peace In The Neighborhood” (which I used to really like but I’m a little more lukewarm on these days). And it would be kind of clever for the Beatles to lead off an album whose title is a pun on an older album title of theirs with a song whose title is a classic Beatle title (“Imagine”) flipped on its head.

    @Tim – You mean you actually added crowd noise? That’s awesome! I’m not too familiar with what you can do in Garage Band yet, it’s one of my long term projects. Now you just need to somehow splice in John Lennon saying “You in the front rows, you can rattle your bloody jewelry.”

  • Tim

    One last comment…I don’t know if this was on purpose, but it was awesome hearing it…

    Listen to Listen. In it, there is a little that is “Wake up and join the human race”. Great call-back to Album #1 :) .

    And yes, I added crowd noise. I thought about adding the “rattle your jewelry” and will be looking into adding Anthology comments over crowd noise, or adding random comments here and there…but I’m not quite sure if I’ll be able to make it work effectively. We’ll see.

  • Brendan

    The Sean idea is genius. You let the cat out of the bag in this entry to why Julian was included in your series. You really were a big fan, the Help Yourself album meant a lot to you, all good. Now if you go with the philosophy that the remaining three would reach out to Julian, then most likely they would do the same to Sean.

    Start with Sean 2006 effort Friendly Fire. The songs Dead Meat and On Again, Off Again are excellent. And I say that not as a Beatles fan, but a fan of inspired music, which that offering was.

  • JamesB

    Within the bounds of the fiction we are creating here, the addition of Sean would seem to be obvious. Also, as George becomes weaker from the illness that eventually kills him, Sean’s addition would allow him to fill that fourth Beatle position. He typically plays all the instruments on his recordings so it would be no problem for him to assume the lead guitar role.

    Of course, that also begs the question of what about Dhani Harrison and Zak Starkey?

  • JamesB

    I guess I should just ask if you have any plans on using Cheer Down? It’s really one of my favorite George tracks he ever did. Also, there are a couple of Traveling Wilbury tracks that would be usable in that they sound like George solo songs because the other Wilburys are only singing backing vocals. I’m thinking of Maxine and Heading for the Light, with a preference for the latter.

    Lastly, Free as a Bird and Real Love?

  • JamesB

    I guess I should just ask if you have any plans on using Cheer Down? It’s really one of my favorite George tracks he ever did. Also, there are a couple of Traveling Wilbury tracks that would be usable in that they sound like George solo songs because the other Wilburys are only singing backing vocals. I’m thinking of Maxine and Heading for the Light, with a preference for the latter.

    Lastly, Free as a Bird and Real Love?

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    While it is a direction, there are so many others. Would Julian have been comfortable with Sean there? Would he have even had a say in the decision? Would the band have considered it because Sean is so close with his mom and relations have always been arms-length and lawyerly between them?

  • mark

    Well, we can debate until we’re blue in the face about whether Julian and Sean could possibly both be in the same band, but I’m going to make the executive decision to (potentially) include a couple Sean songs on the last 2-3 releases, for the simple reason that Julian has only released one album (well, one and a quarter albums) since Help Yourself and as the last three entries stand right now I’ve had to dig way deeper into “Photograph Smile” than I really would like to. This way I can keep the quality standards high. And we can always just pretend they’re all John anyway.

    I’m going to draw the line there though – there’s no need for another Starr or Harrison while the originals still have enough good material to choose from, and they both do, thanks to the existence of “Brainwashed”.

    This is probably a good time to mention that I have read that Julian is going to release a new CD in 2011, so my plan at this point is to do parts 12 and 13 on schedule, but hold off on part 14 until that new CD is released. Does anyone know any details about it? All I’ve been able to find out is that he’s working on it.

  • mark

    Well, we can debate until we’re blue in the face about whether Julian and Sean could possibly both be in the same band, but I’m going to make the executive decision to (potentially) include a couple Sean songs on the last 2-3 releases, for the simple reason that Julian has only released one album (well, one and a quarter albums) since Help Yourself and as the last three entries stand right now I’ve had to dig way deeper into “Photograph Smile” than I really would like to. This way I can keep the quality standards high. And we can always just pretend they’re all John anyway.

    I’m going to draw the line there though – there’s no need for another Starr or Harrison while the originals still have enough good material to choose from, and they both do, thanks to the existence of “Brainwashed”.

    This is probably a good time to mention that I have read that Julian is going to release a new CD in 2011, so my plan at this point is to do parts 12 and 13 on schedule, but hold off on part 14 until that new CD is released. Does anyone know any details about it? All I’ve been able to find out is that he’s working on it.

  • mark

    Well, we can debate until we’re blue in the face about whether Julian and Sean could possibly both be in the same band, but I’m going to make the executive decision to (potentially) include a couple Sean songs on the last 2-3 releases, for the simple reason that Julian has only released one album (well, one and a quarter albums) since Help Yourself and as the last three entries stand right now I’ve had to dig way deeper into “Photograph Smile” than I really would like to. This way I can keep the quality standards high. And we can always just pretend they’re all John anyway.

    I’m going to draw the line there though – there’s no need for another Starr or Harrison while the originals still have enough good material to choose from, and they both do, thanks to the existence of “Brainwashed”.

    This is probably a good time to mention that I have read that Julian is going to release a new CD in 2011, so my plan at this point is to do parts 12 and 13 on schedule, but hold off on part 14 until that new CD is released. Does anyone know any details about it? All I’ve been able to find out is that he’s working on it.

  • JamesB

    Here is what I’ve been able to find from Wikipedia:

    Everything Changes is the sixth studio album by English singer-songwriter Julian Lennon. It is slated to be released in 2011, after an 12-year hiatus following his previous album, Photograph Smile.

    Also:
    Lennon’s sixth album, Everything Changes, is complete and will be released in early 2011.

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    Good news!

  • mark

    So many songs, so little space… I’ve never been that excited about Cheer Down myself, don’t get me wrong, I don’t *dislike* it but it doesn’t do as much for me as the tracks I included. Feel free to add or substitute it for something else, of course, I won’t be offended! =)

    As for Free As a Bird and Real Love, one of them will show up next time (the next album’s date is 1997, which is closer to ’96 than 1993 is). I’ll keep everyone in suspense as to which one.

  • JamesB

    Cool, I hate to offend. :) I was just really unsure how far George’s late 80s songs were being stretched by you. Hard to tell if it had been skipped or was being held for a later album. I’ll find a place for it. If it went on this one it would replace Breath Away from Heaven.

    Btw, good job overall. You’ve opened this longtime Beatles fan to Julian’s music. Thanks for this project.

  • Tim

    Well…live album #1 is done, I think. I conceded…a one CD live album wasn’t going to work, so I went with the double disc and added the encores. The studio tracks don’t sound good “mock” live, but the bootlegged ones sound pretty good – especially with a little added reverb.

    Live album #2′s disc 1 is done. Lots of studio tracks (can’t you pick tracks that have a live counterpart? JEEZ!! ;) . Next up is disc 2 of album #2 and confirming that Live #1 sounds acceptable.

    I also named the live albums:
    Band on the Run Tour album is titled, “Again, At the Hollywood Bowl”
    The Beatles Grow Up Tour album is titled, “Aging on Tour”
    Fab Tour album is titled, “Live in Central Park”

    For the “Central Park” album, I’m thinking of adding a little twist to your track list. It keeps the same songs, with two added. However, there are five tracks in which it isn’t the “Beatles”.
    After “I Don’t Believe You”, I go into the “With a Little Help From My Friends” section:
    1) George Harrison & Paul Simon – Here Comes the Sun*
    2) Ike & Tina Turner – Come Together
    3) Paul McCartney & Stevie Wonder – Ebony and Ivory
    4) U2 – Helter Skelter
    5) Rock and Roll Hall of Fame – While My Guitar Gently Weeps

    * First added track

    I wanted to mix it up a little bit and was going with a “Beatles with Friends Live in Central Park for the Tiananmen Square Protesters.” The last track has the Beatles singing their previously unreleased protest song, “Give Peace a Chance.”**

    ** Second added track

  • Leroy Grey

    It’s the 90′s… no hidden track on the CD?

  • Pingback: Secret Single: Jon Brion, "Sorry Suzanne" | Popdose

  • mark

    Hey, good idea. Maybe that’s what they would’ve done with the little two minute “Cosmically Conscious” section at the end of “C’mon People.”

  • mark

    oh wait, I already suggested that above, didn’t I?

  • mark

    One last little piece of trivia here I just discovered: Wikipedia says that George Harrison played guitar on the “Help Yourself” album but was not credited. Well I’d bet my silk pyjamas that’s him playing the solo and fills on “Saltwater.” Check it out again – who else could it be?

  • JamesB

    The Wikipedia link for Saltwater has this to say:
    The recording features a lead guitar solo in the style of George Harrison. Julian Lennon originally wrote a guitar solo for the song. At the suggestion of his producer Bob Ezrin, he then contacted George Harrison to play the solo instead. George was busy at the time consoling Eric Clapton whose son had recently died. He recorded a couple of riffs and sent them back to Julian. Guitar player Steve Hunter then played the actual solo on the song, combining the solo’s of Julian’s and George’s. In the liner notes for the Help Yourself album George Harrison is given special thanks.