Fixing a Hole: The Beatles’ Imaginary Post-1970 Albums Part 10

Mark Feldman January 4, 2011 14

Part 10: Fab (1989)

I’ve been waiting to write this one for a long time.  In the late ‘80s, as most of us probably remember, the ‘60s became cool again.  Tie dye shirts, stonewashed jeans, covers of ‘60s songs becoming huge hits, Dirty Dancing, the list goes on and on.  So what better time than this for the Beatles to finally embrace their past?  I think as time went on, Tug of Peace and Beatles in Space would be recognized as having some flashes of artistic merit after all, but in 1989 upon release of Fab, I would imagine that this would’ve been hailed as “way better than Beatles in Space,” “their best record in 15 years,” a “return to form,” etc… in the same way that Paul’s Flowers in the Dirt and George’s Cloud Nine were recognized as great later-career statements (though I think Paul was actually disappointed that Flowers wasn’t a bigger success in the US).

Fab is not entirely a throwback album – the production is still very much late ‘80s vintage, and Julian’s material in particular was more forward-looking.  His Mr. Jordan album from 1989 is closer in feel to 1986’s Secret Value of Daydreaming than to his more Beatlesque material that came both earlier and later.  But Mr. Jordan had a higher share of memorable melodies and songs that would fit in with the Beatles than the ’86 album did.

Fab is sequenced to lead off with the four songs that hearken back to the ‘60s the most, one by each Beatle.  This was a marketing ploy, but a clever one. And the album as a whole works as a tasteful combination of looking back and still having something new to say.

Oh, and since we haven’t done this for a while, let’s look at a playlist from the Fab World Tour that just fell through a wormhole in the space-time continuum!  As I mentioned earlier, I think 1989 is about when they’d finally back down and play something from Sergeant Pepper live, since by this point it was more than 20 years ago today…

First Set

When We Was Fab (with a few instrumental bars of “Within You Without You” played in the sitar outtro, suddenly cut off by…)

Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band / With a Little Help From My Friends / Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds

My Brave Face

Valotte

Take It Away

You’re The One

Maybe I’m Amazed

Second Set

Band On the Run

This Is Love

Stick Around

I Don’t Believe You

Come Together

Ebony and Ivory

Helter Skelter (blowing away the cheese)

While My Guitar Gently Weeps

Imagine

A Hard Day’s Night

Encores

Blackbird

Woman

Revolution

All You Need Is Love / She Loves You

Man, if only I could’ve brought the girl I had a crush on junior year of high school to THAT show at Great Woods instead of the B-52’s…

Now onto the long-awaited Fab, the great late ‘80s ‘comeback’ which is probably the Beatles’ best post-1980 album.  It’s also the last one with “sides.”  God I feel old.


Side One:

When We Was Fab” – clearly this was going to be different.  Sitars! Strings! References to the ‘60s!  The fans ate this up in our alternate reality, and I was always surprised it wasn’t quite so eaten up as a Harrison solo tune in our reality.  Sure, people know it, but it was far from his biggest hit.  P.S. – Guess who’s on drums in the video?  Anyway, the nostalgia-fest leads into Paul’s invoking of Rubber Soul with…

My Brave Face” – another one I’m surprised wasn’t more successful at the time.  It just oozes Beatles all over.  It’s not quite as happy a song as the music would have one believe.  Was this autobiographical at all?  I’ve always wondered a little about that.

Sunday Morning” – A Magical Mystery Tour-esque track from Mr. Jordan

I Don’t Believe You” – Another blatant invocation of early Beatle-dom, but I love it anyway.  Ringo didn’t release an album between 1983 and 1992, so I had to borrow from the 1992 album, Time Takes Time, which is surprisingly solid.  We’ll hear more from that album in the future.

This Is Love” – I didn’t originally intend to include this one, but thanks to Dave Steed and his Bottom Feeders series, I gave it another listen, and thought it would fit well here amidst the let’s-revisit-the-‘60s theme.  “Devil’s Radio” was in this spot originally, and will make an appearance next time in a spot I think it fits better as well, so it works all around.

This One” – A track from Flowers in the Dirt that doesn’t get the respect it deserves.  Is it just me or would Billy Joel kill to have written this?

Second Time” – About half of Mr. Jordan consists of truly majestic songs that pull you in and don’t really sound like much else ever recorded.  That’s the half I included here.

SIDE TWO

Figure Of Eight” – Great tune.  I remember CRANKING this song as a 17-year-old so excited about this great new McCartney album, my mom asking me to turn it down and my subsequent “but this is Paul McCartney!  You’ve heard of him!”

You’re The One” – If, if, if… If this had been the first single from Mr. Jordan and not the mostly-devoid-of-melody “Now You’re In Heaven,” the album may have fared much better.  This is a great example of Julian establishing his own style without completely breaking from his roots.  I would say that there’s more than a little Bowie influence on this one too.  Can’t go wrong with that.

Distractions” – An excellent, excellent track from Flowers that I never really noticed much at the time, but recently has become one of my favorites.  I love how the strings and clarinets mix with the light, brushy drums, and the jazzy vocal stylings.

That’s What It Takes” – An excellent, excellent track from Cloud Nine that I never really noticed much at the time, but recently has become one of my favorites.  I’m a sucker for unorthodox chord changes.  Warning: we’re going to be hearing stuff from Cloud Nine for a while, due to lack of George-age for more than a decade afterwards.  Good thing there’s lots to choose from there.  Count your blessings that there wasn’t a long layover after Extra Texture.

Mother Mary” – Love the intro and the dramatic buildups, and that Julian was finally willing to be spiritual (but rock out simultaneously).  Not to mention the not-so-subtle reference to a Beatle song.  A McCartney one, no less.

Put It There” – Most Beatles albums don’t end on a quiet note, but I didn’t think anything else really worked as a finale.  Hey, it just occurred to me that this is kind of an ‘80s “Teddy Boy!”

SINGLES

My Brave Face b/w Open Your Eyes, #2, 1989 (kept out of the #1 spot by Milli Vanilli’s “Baby Don’t Forget My Number”, much to the disgust of Beatle fans across America)

When We Was Fab b/w You Want Her Too, #1, 1989

Figure Of Eight b/w Golden Blunders, #8, 1989

You’re The One b/w Back On My Feet, #17, 1990

WELL-KNOWN SONGS THAT DIDN’T MAKE THE CUT

“Got My Mind Set On You” – sorry folks, couldn’t do it.  Why?  Let the definitive take on this song, heard by clicking on this link, provide the reason.

“Now You’re In Heaven” – edgy and ground-breaking, perhaps, but even “Revolution #9″ has more of a melody.  I don’t see the Beatles letting this on.

Next time… the ‘60s get turned upside down into the ‘90s, and a certain classic album title gets turned upside down, as the Beatles implore us to Help Yourself!

Enhanced by Zemanta
  • jack

    What an unfortunate photo of Julian you chose for this post!

    That’s funny. I always liked “Now You’re In Heaven” and wished more of Mr. Jordan sounded like that!

    Glad to hear more Cloud Nine songs coming, because his ballads on that release are amazing. “Someplace Else” has a beautiful slide guitar melody and the tune wouldn’t be out of place on All Things Must Pass.

  • Anonymous

    Dude, “Got My Mind Set On You” was not only a huge number one hit for George, it was the number three song of the YEAR in 1988 (beat out by INXS’ “Need You Tonight” and George Michael’s “Faith”)!! Knowing this in hindsight, it seems ludicrous not to include it, not just because the song would have made the album that much more of a big seller, but also since it fits the ’60s throwback theme – it would have been the first time the Beatles scored a big hit with a cover (James Ray first recorded it in 1962) since “Twist and Shout.” Doubtless George was laughing his ass off when he heard the Weird Al version too. If it were me, I’d knock off “Second Time,” move “Put it There” to the end of side 1, and end side 2 with “Got My Mind Set On You.”

    Also, regarding “My Brave Face,” it’s one of those album’s worth of McCartney-Costello collaborations that dribbled out between ’87 and ’96, and those lyrics sound an awful lot like something Elvis would write.

  • mark

    I agree that if one was going to include it, that would be a good way to do it – have it end the album and move Put It There to the end of side 1. You wouldn’t even have to delete “Second Time” – by 1989, 60 minute albums were starting to become commonplace. Second Time could be a CD-and-cassette-only bonus track if it made the album too long for a single LP. And I suppose if Got My Mind Set On You weren’t on here, then we’d never get to hear Weird Al’s version in the alternate reality, so that’s reason alone.

    That’s a good point about the lyrics to My Brave Face being Costello-esque, I never really thought of that, but it makes sense.

  • http://twitter.com/mordalo Mordalo

    I find it fascinating you’re still referring to “Side One” and “Side Two” at this point, unless compact discs didn’t take hold in this alternate reality.

    Given that they were the de facto standard in the late 80′s, I’m surprised they’re still releasing LP’s.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Cassettes were still pretty popular in ’89.

  • Anonymous

    The first album to reach number one on the Billboard charts that did not have a vinyl counterpart was Vanilla Ice’s “To The Extreme,” which was released in August of 1990. Like Jeff said, cassettes were still very popular in the late ’80s (they were still, as I recall, the top selling format over CDs and vinyl at that time), especially among the under-20 crowd. Kids that age couldn’t afford CDs. In some cases they were as much as double the price of cassettes.

    Also, to dispel a popular misconception, LPs never died! The titles released became more and more limited and often you had to import them from other countries if you couldn’t find a US pressing, but the fact is, they were released all through the ’90s. Nowadays they’re even more popular than they were in the ’90s, so we’re seeing many of the titles that never made it onto LP in the US back then making their LP debut now.

  • http://twitter.com/mordalo Mordalo

    Eh, senility must be kicking in. I was 22 in ’89, and I didn’t even think about cassettes, even though I had my share of them.

  • James B

    I really hope we get to hear George’s “Just for Today” on an upcoming album. That guitar solo never fails to make the hairs on my arm stand on end. It’s magical. Also, “Cheer Down” is one of my favorite George tracks ever and I hope it makes the cut too.

  • http://twitter.com/tcote Thierry Côté

    No room for Paul’s charming “Livin’ on a Prayer” ripoff, “Où Est Le Soleil?” ;)

  • James B

    Looking back to the late Seventies….

    If you cannot justify putting Silly Love Songs and Mull of Kintyre on the ’77 album, I would propose they be released a Beatles double-A side single. They were both huge hits and if the Beatles had released them they would be all that much bigger. I don’t think they should be ignored despite a preference against them.

  • Tim

    You want to know why there are fewer and fewer comments? The lack of updates. Wasn’t it said that there would an attempt at once a week (skipping a few weeks here and there)? We’re now sitting at 2 weeks after the last update…and five months since the start of the Fixing a Hole. At 10 parts, that’s that’s one every other week. I’m loving this…creating playlists based on them and burning them to CD – even labeling them as “The Beatles”. This is a ton of fun…but the waits are killing me!

    But really…take it as a good thing that I’m impatient for these updates :) .

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    I can’t speak for Mark, but I will say for my own part, our work for Popdose is genuinely a labor of love, not money. We’re doing this on our own time & dime, so when the bills come due and the car motor dies and the internet gets shut off and the etc. to the etc. happens, as much as we’d rather do this, we’re rather stuck doing that.

    It is, I’m sure, very pleasing to Mark that the readers are chomping at the bit for the next installment. Better to be wanted, right? I’m sure another edition will soon be on the way.

  • Tim

    Definitely. It’s frustrating that there isn’t a more consistent schedule to me, the reader. But, Mark should be proud of his work that we’re “chomping at the bit”.

    I just think people these days are impatient and when there wasn’t an update for awhile, people forgot and/or stopped checking.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    The every-other-week thing is my fault. I’ve been spacing them out, because I don’t want the series to end.