Greatest Un-Hits: The Rolling Stones’ “Like a Rolling Stone” (1995)

Brian Boone August 10, 2011 13

Pictured: not the Rolling Stones.

In 1994, after more than 30 years largely intact and as one of the world’s best, most famous, popular, and hardworking bands, the Rolling Stones experienced a major shift. That was the year the core members of the band were replaced whole cloth by a French Rolling Stones cover band called Les Hommes de Combats de Rues. Mick Jagger was approaching 70 and ready to retire from the rock n’ roll grind, and had seen Les Hommes in a cabaret show in 1991. (The name is ironic, too; for while Les Hommes means “the men,” Les Hommes de Combats de Rues – literally “the men who fight in the streets,” a literal translation of “street fighting men” – all members of the band were reverse drag performers, which is to say women dressed as men.)

The thing is that Jagger, Richards, et all, didn’t want to give up the lucrative revenues generated by the Rolling Stones brand, merely the work. So they retained ownership and paid Les Hommes de Combats de Rues to replace the real Rolling Stones on stage and on record. The first album released by the faux-Stones was 1994′s Voodoo Lounge. Absolutely nobody noticed that the Stones weren’t the Stones. That’s because they were very convincing replicants. The “Mick Jagger” does all those exaggeratedly silly Mick Jagger dance moves, while the former prostitute that portrays Keith Richards really looks like she did a bunch of heroin to prepare for the role (and she probably did).

The result was a band more convincing – and, because of the unique corporate arrangement – more successful than Bjorn Again and Beatlemania put together. But Voodoo Lounge, despite the hype and commercial push to get the new band in front of as many people as possible (while hoping none of them were the wiser), sales were lackluster, as a Rolling Stones album in the era of grunge and Britpop wasn’t the coolest prospect. As a last ditch effort, the faux Stones recorded a cover of Bob Dylan’s “Like a Rolling Stone,” a self-conscious, self-aware novelty song of sorts that was sort of about themselves, or was at the very least self-referential.  Get it? Like  a rolling stone? Because they were a cover band? Yeah?

It did not renew interest in the Stones. Less successful than even Voodoo Lounge, this song failed to even reach the Billboard Hot 100.

 

  • Peter

    It was actually a pretty good cover, and a more than decent album.  Supposedly Dylan started doing bizarre Stones covers in reverse tribute or mockery or whatever.

  • jesselun

    Voodoo Lounge had some great songs…so did Bridges to Babylon…underrated albums

  • jedgeco

    Whatever record this came off of (“Stripped”?) was worth it for the fantastic versions of “Wild Horses” and “Dead Flowers.”

  • JT

    strange write up…
    Its a really great cover…I rarely hear it played though

    the album stripped sold a 1 million copies- thats not so bad for a live album (an expensive one at that b/c VIRGIN albums were more expensive back in the day

  • JT

    strange write up…
    Its a really great cover…I rarely hear it played though

    the album stripped sold a 1 million copies- thats not so bad for a live album (an expensive one at that b/c VIRGIN albums were more expensive back in the day

  • JT

    strange write up…
    Its a really great cover…I rarely hear it played though

    the album stripped sold a 1 million copies- thats not so bad for a live album (an expensive one at that b/c VIRGIN albums were more expensive back in the day

  • Dumpster Baby

    I realize you were trying to be funny here but it did not work.  This is silly..you trivialize this great song and speak of Voodoo Lounge like it was a throwaway.  That was a good record and has held up well.

  • David_E

    Self-referential silliness aside, it’s not a bad cover at all. Reminds me of the DBT’s version (which I prefer, but still). Cool video, too.

  • jamesballenger

    Love the whole album it came from. And the video is just amazing. Pretty sure Michel Gondry did it. Yes he did!
    Sorry Mr Boone, your attempt at silliness was only successful in that it was silly.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Count me among the “Voodoo Rest Home” haters. Blech.

  • Shaun

    Yeah… This was kinda dumb. The article, I mean.

    Voodoo Lounge, which I owned once a time, was decent. Not great, but decent. Its predecessor, Steel Wheels, actually was a pretty great album IMO. Not Exile On Main Street or Beggar’s Banquet, no, but still really good.I eventually tired of Vood Lounge and sold it to a used store, but I’m not ashamed to say I owned it. It had some good songs.

    And that live album with “Like a Rolling Stone” on it? That was called Stripped, since it was taken from a small club show(s) the band played and featured the band in  a”stripped” down setting and arrangements. It’s a fan-f*cking-tastic live album. Seriously. Great cover of LaRS too.

    Ok, the part about an old prostitute playing the part of Keith made me chuckle.

  • Shaun

    Yup… It was Stripped. A truly great live album, which showed the band still had its chops. They still do, really, although they really haven’t a ton of great recent songs. Possibly the best live album the band ever made, although Get Your Ya-Ya’s Out is pretty awesome too.

  • http://twitter.com/mordalo Mordalo

    Popular artist replaced by cover band.

    So you’re telling me that Mick Jagger’s really in a nursing home with a Black President Kennedy?