Into the Ear of Madness: Week 16 — Caught in the Middle of McD’s Rhodes and Foster’s Acoustic Grand

Logo

Over the next year Terje Fjelde has agreed to listen to nothing but David Foster on his iPod. He’s loaded the thing with over 1,200 songs produced, arranged, composed, and/or played by David Foster. A deal with the devil? He keeps wondering.

Today’s entry is dedicated in its entirety to a genuine soft rock classic, a formidable milestone which embodies just about everything I love about this kind of music. It’s more or less a re-post of an entry I did for my own blog a couple of year ago, but no one read it then and I can’t think of a better way to describe it, so here we go:

Kenny Loggins – “Heart to Heart,” from High Adventure (1982)

Kenny Loggins was never the one who kicked you in the ass with his no-nonsense musical attitude. He’s more like the musical equivalent of a friendly pat on the shoulder – and yes, he’s frequently nonsensical. But that doesn’t really bother me. He’s had a couple of magical moments in his career, and this is one of them. As far as I’m concerned, “Heart to Heart” is the definition of smooth music – and I mean that in a good way. It was co-written by Loggins with Michael McDonald and David Foster.

The song is firmly rooted in 1982. There’s a synth ambiance, but it’s tasteful and discrete. It has a warm and analogue feel. Had he recorded this a year later, the acoustic piano riffs would’ve been “Jump”-style synth riffs fronting a static synth bass and drum machines. A couple of years earlier, and he’d surely have vocoded the background vocals to a disco beat or something like that. Thank God for 1982.

From the three opening chords you can tell this is going to be done just right. On the one hand you’ve got Michael McDonald starting up his groove on the Fender Rhodes, on the other you’ve got David Foster syncopating away on his acoustic piano. Enter two percussionists (Lenny Castro and Paulinho Da Costa), a drummer (Tris Imboden – the guy who replaced Danny Seraphine in Chicago) and some excellent thumb bass fills (courtesy of Derek Jackson), and we’re off.

This is it.

The musical bed is rhythmically intricate, yet still somehow all soft and comfortable. There’s a little bit of jazz, and a little bit of R&B. Loggins’ vocals are as light as a fluffy pillow and the whole darn thing just smells as fresh as a daisy in the field. (used in accordance with The Intentional Use of Cliché-Ridden Idioms Act).

Mike Hamilton’s credited on guitar, but I can’t hear him anywhere. Enter some strings in the pre-chorus (courtesy of Toto-dad Marty Paich, which to me suggests they’re real, but I’m not sure) to bring on that floating feeling.

Richard Page and Steve George do McDonald Light on background vocals. It’s hard to believe the ‘daar-liin’ part was done without McDonald; it’s my only complaint – he should’ve been there. Page and George (of Pages and Mr. Mister) are still great, and their vocal stylings are appropriately dominant throughout the tune. David Sanborn plays an insightful and beautifully logical pop-sax-solo and it all fades out far too soon at 5 minutes and 21 seconds.

The lyric’s about a guy in a relationship that’s on the verge of collapse, but he figures they may have one more shot if they open up “heart to heart” – it sounds decent enough for a Loggins song, but I’m never able to concentrate on the lyrics anyway.

I’m always caught somewhere in the middle between McD’s Rhodes and Foster’s Acoustic Grand. And what a great place to be in 1982.

The album High Adventure was released in 1982. “Heart To Heart” was released as a single in late ‘82 or early ‘83, peaking at #15 on the US Pop Charts and at #3 on the AC charts.

Tags: , , ,

  • Sharon
    As a follow up on Loggins-Foster, I was listening to "Love at Second Sight" (I'm slowly building up my Foster collection-only about 1000 to go!), and near the end of the song where you can hear a strong Chicago-like sound, there is a piece that is exactly the beginning of "Forever", Loggins follow-up to 'High Adventure', 'Vox Humana'. "Forever" is another Loggins-Foster collaboration. After the "Forever" sound, on "Second Sight", it's followed by a strong Asia sound.
    Just my little contribution to Terje's nuggets of info.
  • DavidLG1971
    An older brother of mine had this LP. I remember us arguing over who was singing the back-ups - at age 11, I was sure it was Michael McDonald.

    Anyway, at the time my bro told me that Richard Page got his start in LA by being able to impersonate other (trendy) vocalists, chief among them Michael McDonald, who was THE background singer of the late 1970s. As proof, he played one of Carol Bayer Sager's album from around the same time (at the time Mrs. Burt Bacharach, for those unaware). Sure enough, a lot of backgrounds sound like Michael McDonald, and yet it's all Richard Page.

    So I presume it's Page on Heart to Heart, though my ears don't really believe it.

    That track has most of my favorite LA session musicians of the era on it - Foster on piano, McDonald on Fender Rhodes (though Greg Phillinganes would have been fine too), Sanborn on sax, Imboden on drums. Is Nathan East on bass? I can't remember.

    All it needs is Bill Champlin breathing (in key) in the background somewhere, and it'd top After The Love Has Gone as my favorite Foster session.
  • hagen
    Before the next one arrives, I should mention I've never heard this song before. Congratulations, Terje, on exposing my lack of Loggins education. You make a formidable adversary, Terje, but I'm not afraid. Not yet, anyway. Good tune, too. Next?
  • Oh, but you should be afraid.
  • Eric S.
    For a minute I thought you were going to tell us that Foster had a hand in "Don't Fight It" from the same album. Had that been the case, I might have raised him a level on the Crap-O-Meter. But as I look at the liner notes, I see Steve Perry and Neil Geraldo get the credit. I guess Foster and McD had enough sense to stick with what they knew.
  • I was horrified when I came home to spin High Adventure, my very first Kenny Loggins album, and "Don't Fight It" came out of the speakers. And it's followed by "Heartlight" which isn't much better.
  • MichaelFortes
    I remember vividly the day that I acquired this 45 (which, btw, in the single version had some of that intro chopped off and faded out about 45 seconds earlier than the LP version). It was February of '83, and my uncle took me to a record store in Providence to pick out some singles for my birthday (I also got ABC's "The Look of Love" and Men at Work's "Down Under" that day, and some others I can't quite remember at the moment). Man, was I happy to finally have that record. In fact, I still have it! But you know, I never ever noticed Foster's name on the credits before, probably because I haven't looked at the record in four years or more. And I agree with everyone who says that it sounds like McDonald is in there somewhere. If he really isn't, they did a damn good job of recreating his sound.
  • mojo
    McD...hahahaha...the Big Mac of session men. So bad, and so bad for you. And loaded with cheese, trans fats, special sauce, whatnot. Reconstituted onions, too. Delish!
  • WHarrisBullzEye
    Never ever did I imagine that that wasn't Michael McDonald. I have lived a lie.
  • Pete
    I love this track. A friend put it on a mix for me last year and I played the crap out of it. I would have thought that was McD on the backing vocals as well, as it's definitely his style.
  • David_E
    Terje, you are so right about the "McDonald light" vocals. I have spent most of the last 26 years assuming it WAS McD. Now I feel like a fool.

    Are you sure?? Not even the punctuating "I know" in the last line of each chorus?

    Damn.
  • Well, if I were to trust my ears, I'd swear McDonald was in there, but according to the liner notes he's not. Liner notes aren't always accurate, though - as I mentioned, Mike Hamilton's credited on guitar but I can't find a single recognizable guitar sound on this track. And why wouldn't they use his voice once he's in the studio anyway?
  • I say forget the liners. That's gotta be McD.
  • I don't know - I listened very closely to the background vocals on my hilariously expensive headset this afternoon - and I concluded that it's only Page and George - no McD. But there's no doubt that Page is consciously emulating the McD vibrato.
  • Fuck your stupid conclusion. It's McD, dammit.
  • Oh well, I lied anyway. My headset is only moderately expensive.
blog comments powered by Disqus