Rock Court, Small Claims Division: Ben E. King vs. The Police

Dw. Dunphy January 22, 2010 4

All rise.

The terms of this courtroom are simple. You will be presented with two songs, one by the plaintiff and one by the defendant. It is your task to decide if the defendant’s track is only coincidentally similar to the plaintiffs or, as members of the Bar Association put it, someone got caught with their fingers in the cookie jar. You have been duly instructed.

Today’s docket: Ben E. King, plaintiff vs. The Police, defendants

Ben E. King – Stand By Me from Don’t Play That Song (1962)

The verses have virtually the same melody, so much so that several mash-ups were made of the two songs. Damning evidence indeed!

The Police – Every Breath You Take from Synchronicity (1983)

What about the bridge? If that bridge don’t fit, you must acquit! (Oh, and since when did Ben E. King sing about stalking? Hmmm?)

Do you stand by Sting?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …
  • JT

    Both songs are so good…that we should just call the whole thing off.

  • breadalbane

    Hmmmm….just like the regular court system, this court seems inclined to favour The Police.

    Incidentally, King himself based “Stand By Me” on a version of the spiritual “Lord, Stand By Me”. Which means I'm looking forward to next week's Rock Court: King vs. God.

  • breadalbane

    Hmmmm….just like the regular court system, this court seems inclined to favour The Police.

    Incidentally, King himself based “Stand By Me” on a version of the spiritual “Lord, Stand By Me”. Which means I'm looking forward to next week's Rock Court: King vs. God.

  • Magkfingrs

    How about “Trying to live my life without you” by Otis Clay/Bob Seger vs. The Long Run by the Eagles…I've always thought Henley and boys ripped that one off…