Rock Court, Small Claims Division: The Grateful Dead v. Fleetwood Mac

Dw. Dunphy April 16, 2010 6

All rise.

The rules of this courtroom are simple. You will be presented with two songs, one by the plaintiff and one by the defendant. It is your task to decide if the defendant’s track is only coincidentally similar to the plaintiffs or, as members of the Bar Association put it, like, oh wow, bro. Not cool! You have been duly instructed.

Today’s docket: Fleetwood Mac, plaintiff vs. The Grateful Dead, defendant

Fleetwood Mac – “Station Man” from Kiln House (1970)

Come on, man. Same groove. Just because you pulled from the Kirwan era of the band, you think you’ll get away with it?

The Grateful Dead – “Passenger” from Terrapin Station (1977)

Come on, man. You can’t copyright a groove. Plus, we’re a jam band. We improv, we rearrange, we jam! We’re just doing our thing!

Is this plagiarism, man?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …
  • Chaloga

    The surviving Dead should pay Danny Kirwan royalties. He could sure use the money, he's a homeless alcoholic today…

  • http://www.burningdervish.com Burning Dervish

    oddly enough, keith olson produced fleetwood mac's 1975 fleetwood mac record and terrapin station, the dead album with passenger on int

  • KidCharlemagne

    I think it is a draw….so Stevie Nick's exposed torso trumps Donna Jean any day of the week.

  • carolsiriusb

    No contest. You have to be kidding… no comparison. One is a song and the other is still just an idea. And that is really boring for a Mac song too. 'course, they didn'y have Jerry who made music out of mere ideas…

  • eddiev54

    Look, the Dead did this alot – more than we care to think about it. If you want a good example of their “borrowings” comapre “Shakedown Street” to the Bee Gees “Staying Alive.”

  • notarealdoctor

    It’s close. . . But NOT the most egregious Dead lifting of another song. Check out Franklin’s Tower vs. Lou Reed’s Coney Island Baby. It’s the same tune.
    Really, though, there are only so many rock songs you can write. Only monetarily does it matter, if at all.