Secret Single: Genesis, “Paperlate”

Dw. Dunphy March 17, 2011 10

In May 1982, Genesis was on their way to becoming superstars. Phil Collins had just stepped out to great success, one year earlier, with the Face Value album. The band secured hits with “Turn It On Again,” “Misunderstanding” and “No Reply At All” (from Duke and Abacab, respectively) and proven that, beyond more than a decade as prog rockers, they were ready for the Top of the Pops.

Released as a three-track EP, 3X3 appeared in the UK before the release of the band’s live recording Three Sides Live. That album would include, on the fourth record side, all three songs from the EP plus two others, “Evidence of Autumn” and “Open Door,” b-sides recorded years earlier with producer David Hentschel.

The single appeared in the US with “Paperlate” as the single side and “You Might Recall” as the backing b-side. Why Atlantic, or other US labels for that matter, was so reticent about singles including more than two songs, I do not know; I do know that it was an extremely rare occurrence though. One assumes they believed offering three of the five “new to you” tracks would undercut sales for the album.

The song went to #10 on the US charts, drove up sales for Three Sides Live, and I assume provided justification for Atlantic’s decision. The song itself, while catchy and enjoyable, also is a definite cousin to “No Reply At All,” both songs employing the same tempo, attitude and the Earth, Wind and Fire horn section.

The three songs that comprise 3X3 were, for long periods of time, not available on US domestic CD. The release (and subsequent remastering) of Three Sides Live omitted the entire studio side. When the Genesis Archive Vol. 2 came out, it only included “Paperlate” and “You Might Recall”. Collins has voiced a dislike for “Me and Virgil,” a track he classified as a failed attempt to write a song like The Band. You can actually hear a faint similarity to the structure of “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down” in the track, so it is an easily swallowed alibi.

With the release of the Genesis 1976-1982 box set, an additional disc was included with remasters of the albums from the specified time period and included all of the Three Sides Live studio tracks as well as other b-sides.

Paperlate

You Might Recall

Me and Virgil

 

Enhanced by Zemanta
  • Pingback: Platters that matter: 20 albums that changed my life (#10—#1) | The Man in the Gray Flannel Suit

  • Anonymous

    As I mentioned when it popped up on Bottom Feeders a few months back, “You Might Recall” is easily my favorite of the fourth studio side of 3SL. Could I see it as an A-side? Maybe not, but I’m glad it showed up on a more economic alternative to the double album.

    How’s the remastering on the bonus disc for 76-82? I own the reissues for Duke and Abacab and they don’t suffer from loudness as much as brightness. Phil sounds like he’s smiling throughout the entire sessions (not much of a stretch, I grant you).

  • http://www.grayflannelsuit.net/ Chris Holmes

    “You Might Recall” is great, but “Evidence of Autumn” is absolutely my favorite song from the original D side.

  • Anonymous

    It is also worth noting that the U.S. and U.K. versions of the original vinyl Three Sides Live – an album primarily documenting the tour in support of Abacab – each contain a different Side 4. The Side 4 you describe above is the American version. The U.K. version’s 4th side included a few other live tracks recorded on tours that predated Abacab, in lieu of the studio b-sides. When the ’90s CD remasters appeared, it was decided that the U.K. version would appear worldwide, hence the disappearance of those studio b-sides from the American version of the CD. It should also now be clear why Atlantic would only want two songs on the single while Charisma in the U.K. saw no problem with adding a third, since in the U.K. there would be no issue at all with undercutting sales of the album.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XFYCHNKEEEY7CIJBFGT3W73LEM ShannonB

    Ever since I was a kid I thought this song was called paper lady and its about a paper lady.

  • http://www.jasonhare.com Anonymous

    There are days where I just play “Paperlate” on repeat from start to finish.

  • http://www.jasonhare.com Anonymous

    There are days where I just play “Paperlate” on repeat from start to finish.

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    This is probably close to the end of my favorite period for the band, Duke-through-Genesis. While I love Invisible Touch and We Can’t Dance, this was the point when they had tons of pop ambition but didn’t seem to be specifically aiming for it, which was nice.

  • Old_Davy

    “Evidence Of Autumn” is one of my favorite Tony Banks compositions ever. Absolutely gorgeous!

  • Francis

    “You Might Recall” is my favorite Genesis song, Phil-era or Peter-era. “Me and Virgil” is … well, let’s just say it re-raised Phil Collins in my esteem to know that he doesn’t like it either.