Song-Off: An Introduction

Popdose Staff May 20, 2008 16

Photo by suttonhoo

Animotion – “Obsession”

Ladies and gentlemen…LET’S GET READY TO RUMBLE!!!

Next week we’ll be unveiling a new feature here at Popdose: the Song-Off. Two songs about similar topic will be pitted against each other in a no-holds-barred grudge match. And much like the tried and true system of American democracy, Popdose voters will have the opportunity to elect their favorite based on not only the merits of the songs themselves, but also based on distortions, factually inaccurate claims, character smears, whisper campaigns, and ad hominem attacks advanced by the pair of Popdose writers who were brave enough to step into the ring and advocate for their chosen song. It’ll be just like Thunderdome, except instead of one slobbering imbecile (I’m speaking of Mel Gibson, of course), there will be two, chasing each other around in increasingly irrelevant circles with rhetorical chainsaws.

We’ll be taking on song topics like “Aeroplanes,” and “Pastel-Colored Moons,” and “Incestuous Father-Daughter Relationships and the Second Amendment.” In the future, we’ll even hold a few tournaments, such as the eagerly anticipated Monkey Madness tournament to see who can climb to the top of the “Monkey-Related-Violence” bracket, and whether they can sling enough feces to subdue the silverback who emerges triumphantly from the bracket of “Miscellaneous Primates.”

Join us next week as Jeff Giles and Jon Cummings match their so-called “wits” in our first contest. Despite the fact that neither of them has ever been on a carnival ride or kissed a girl without getting Maced, they’ll be debating a pair of songs that feature that time-honored makeout tradition, the Tunnel of Love. Stay tuned!

  • http://www.drcastrato.blogspot.com drcastrato

    ooooh, what a teaser! i'm already too excited. just bring it!

  • JonCummings

    Well, the good news is that over the years I've become impervious (emphasis on perv) to Mace. Restraining orders, too. Billy clubs and jacknives I still have problems with occasionally.

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    Dire Straits beats Bruce Springsteen and that's my bottom line.

  • http://www.popdose.com Zack

    You're not even going to listen to the arguments?

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    I'll listen to the arguments. I'm a good sport, but let us just say that I have an emotional investment in “Making Movies” side one & The Boss will need a stellar defense to win me over…

    Or money. If Springsteen sends me a bunch o'cash, I could be persuaded.

  • http://jackfear.blogspot.com Jack Feerick

    ..and in a dark horse upset, Fun Boy Three beats 'em both!

  • http://retro-remixes.blogspot.com Retro_Remixes

    I'm now fully aroused.

    And for no particular reason, here are a bunch of Obsession remixes:

    http://retro-remixes.blogspot.com/2007/07/animo…

  • http://notthatyoung.blogspot.com Steve

    Oooooo…Obsession!

    Gimme front row seats for this one.

    It's gonna get *real* ugly!

  • http://www.popdose.com Zack

    Congratulations, you just volunteered to advocate for “Skateaway” when Rollergirl is the topic.

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    And I will, too. Throw in “Romeo And Juliet” vs. Steve Forbert and you have me there, too.

  • Old_Davy

    Put Steve Forbert up against Indigo Girls in round 1. I've never heard Forbert's version, but I like it more than the IG version already. I normally love Indigo Girls, but their version of “Romeo and Juliet” bites.

  • http://www.popdose.com Zack

    I'd actually been planning to match up the Velvet Underground/Lou Reed song “Romeo and Juliet” against Dire Straits, but Dire Straits is already pretty heavily represented, so maybe I'll let Forbert take Reed on instead.

  • Old_Davy

    Put Steve Forbert up against Indigo Girls in round 1. I've never heard Forbert's version, but I like it more than the IG version already. I normally love Indigo Girls, but their version of “Romeo and Juliet” bites.

  • http://www.popdose.com Zack

    I'd actually been planning to match up the Velvet Underground/Lou Reed song “Romeo and Juliet” against Dire Straits, but Dire Straits is already pretty heavily represented, so maybe I'll let Forbert take Reed on instead.

  • Old_Davy

    Put Steve Forbert up against Indigo Girls in round 1. I've never heard Forbert's version, but I like it more than the IG version already. I normally love Indigo Girls, but their version of “Romeo and Juliet” bites.

  • http://www.popdose.com Zack

    I'd actually been planning to match up the Velvet Underground/Lou Reed song “Romeo and Juliet” against Dire Straits, but Dire Straits is already pretty heavily represented, so maybe I'll let Forbert take Reed on instead.