Soundtrack Saturday: “Grace of My Heart”

If you regularly read this column, I guess you noticed that there was no Soundtrack Saturday last week. I had a technology meltdown a couple of weeks ago that resulted in the death of my laptop and the temporary interruption of my Internet connection. I purchased a new laptop, but I was having it customized, which took a week; my Internet connection returned, but I was forced to use my ancient desktop, which runs on Windows 98. I’m lucky I could use the Internet at all — I think that computer is more suited for a game of Oregon Trail. The whole situation was a nightmare, and I felt like someone had hacked off an arm and replaced it with a Wiffle ball bat.

But all is well now. My new laptop is wonderful, Internet is all fixed, and I feel whole again. I hope you didn’t miss me too much.

Now, on with the show. I know Ferris Bueller’s Day Off is a tough post to follow, but I hope you’ll enjoy this week’s pick. Directed by Allison Anders, Grace of My Heart (1996) tells the story of Edna Buxton (a.k.a. Denise Waverly), an aspiring singer-songwriter who turns to writing songs for other artists when she’s told there’s no place for her own songs in the early-’60s musical landscape. The film uses Carole King’s life and career as a fairly obvious template and follows Edna/Denise through two decades of personal and professional challenges, including two failed marriages — one to a Gerry Goffin-like songwriter (Eric Stoltz), the other to a Brian Wilson-type musical genius (Matt Dillon); an affair with a married DJ (Bruce Davison); raising kids as a single mother; dealing with the competition of other songwritiers (Patsy Kensit and Chris Isaak); handling her over-the-top agent (John Turturro); and trying to make her own singing career a success.

Though Grace of My Heart didn’t receive rapturous critical acclaim or even decent box-office returns when it came out in the fall of ‘96, I think it’s an excellent film with an outstanding star turn by Douglas and great direction by Anders.

The soundtrack has a story just as interesting as that of Douglas’s character. Produced by Larry Klein, Joni Mitchell’s former husband and producer, it contains a plethora of songs that sound like they came straight from the Brill Building in the ’60s, written and performed by an incredible roster of performers and songwriters, including Elvis Costello, J Mascis (of Dinosaur Jr.), Gerry and Louise Goffin, Shawn Colvin, Lesley Gore, Jill Sobule, and Los Lobos. Though it appears Douglas herself is singing in the film, her vocals were actually performed by actress-singer Kristen Vigard (fans of the recently canceled soap opera Guiding Light will remember her as ingenue Morgan Richards, a popular character on the show in the early ’80s).

The official soundtrack is pretty fantastic, but there are a few disappointments. Half of the songs performed by the film’s fictional girl group, the Luminaries, are omitted, as is one song by the Williams Brothers. Vigard’s version of “Hey There,” the song that kicks off Edna’s career in the film, is also left out, and her performance of  “In Another World” is replaced by R&B group Portrait’s version. The most obvious substitution on the soundtrack is that of the Elvis Costello-and-Burt Bacharach-penned “God Give Me Strength”: Vigard’s vocals are used in the film, but the Costello-Bacharach version appears on the soundtrack.

Another interesting substitution is that of “Man From Mars” by Joni Mitchell. Though performed by Vigard in the film, a version by Mitchell appeared on the soundtrack album’s first pressing; it was eventually pulled, and subsequent pressings include Vigard’s rendition of the song.

From what I can tell, the soundtrack is pretty much out of print or very difficult to find these days, so I’ve provided the whole thing below as well as several additional tracks. There were quite a few songs that I couldn’t find, but I did manage to dig up some YouTube clips so you could at least hear them. Enjoy!

Portrait – In Another World
For Real – Born to Love That Boy
For Real – Unwanted Number
For Real – I Do
Miss Lily Banquette – My Secret Love
The Williams Brothers – Love Doesn’t Ever Fail Us
Jill Sobule – Truth Is You Lied
J Mascis – Take a Run at the Sun
Kristen Vigard – God Give Me Strength
Tiffany Anders and Boyd Rice – Absence Makes the Heart Grow Fonder
Sonic Youth – Little Trouble Girl
Juned – Groovin’ on You
The Bell Sisters – Bermuda
J Mascis – Don’t You Think It’s Time
Kristen Vigard – Man From Mars
Shawn Colvin – Between Two Worlds
Kristen Vigard – A Boat on the Sea
Elvis Costello with Burt Bacharach – God Give Me Strength

Wendy Williams, “Blues Ain’t Nothin’ But a Woman Crying for Her Man”

Kristen Vigard, “Hey There”

Kristen Vigard, “In Another World”

For Real, “Blues Ain’t Nothin’ But a Woman Crying for Her Man”

  • This is one of my favorite features on the site. Last week I was left to wonder, "Where's my Soundtrack Saturday soundtrack?"
  • I really liked "Grace of My Heart" when I saw it in '97 or so, especially the way in which Anders mixed up many elements of '60s pop history to represent Edna's story. And even if that's not Illeana Douglas singing "God Give Me Strength" in the film, her lip-synching is the most emotionally affecting lip-synching I've ever seen. I saw her last year in a low-budget shot-in-Chicago film called "Osso Bucco"; it made me sad, because she deserves so much better.
  • KellyStitzel
    I won't deny that when I was writing this post, I sang along loudly and passionately to Vigard's version of "God Give Me Strength" at least 5 times.
  • JonCummings
    Robert is exactly right here--I remember this scene exactly the same way. Douglas works the gestures and (especially) her eyes in a brilliant way as she "sings" the song.
  • WHarrisBullzEye
    Love it. I came because of the Costello / Bacharach collab, but I love the Williams Brothers and J. Mascis contributions as well, and For Real's "I Do" is great, too.
  • What the hell happened to the Williams Brothers, anyway? I demand a Hooks 'N' You devoted to their career...
  • WHarrisBullzEye
    Who the hell are you to demand...oh, right. Coming right up, sir!
  • Didn't you do a Cutouts Gone Wild about them at Jefitoblog in '06, Jeff? I still have one or two of their songs from that post. "How Long" -- is that one of their songs?
  • Wow, that's some memory you've got there...yes, I did do a post on their first Warner Bros. album, the long-forgotten "Two Stories."
  • JonCummings
    "Editor-in-Chiefing for Dummies," Chapter 4, page 43: "When asking a reporter to cover a particular topic, don't cross your arms and bellow like Yul Brynner in 'The King and I.' Simply say, 'I'd like to assign you to write a column devoted to the Williams Brothers.' We cannot all be Perry White in the 'Superman' movies. Remember that many reporters harbor an enormous distrust of authority; you don't want to alienate them."
  • Say, did our own Ms. Logue write that book?
  • side3
    Vigard's version of "God Give Me Strength" is at least as good as Elvis Costello's...and that is saying a lot.

    The first time I heard EC sing this song (on Letterman), I literally get goosebumps...
  • jhallCORE
    Kelly,

    Thanks for the writeup of the soundtrack and film. Always liked the film and it occasionally resurfaces every now and then. Always been a fan of Douglas and yeah, it would be nice to see her in more films. Stole a lot of scenes in "To Die For" if I recall correctly.

    The Costello/Bacharach version of "God Give Me Strength" plays over the film's closing credits. One disappointing omission from the soundtrack is the title song from the end of the film when Edna/Illeana reflects back on her life as she finally puts out her solo album. I think Kristen Vigard handles vocal duties on that one too.

    In regard to Kristen Vigard, I seem to remember her putting out a self-titled solo album back in 1990. Did a nice cover of Bill Withers' "Use Me."

    Thanks again for the soundtrack/film review. Keep 'em coming.
  • I know I had an mp3 of the Joni Mitchell version of "Man from Mars" at one point (different than the version that appears on "Taming the Tiger"). I'll try to find it and post it. (No promises, though -- my file organization is not the best.)
  • Matthew B
    Thank you so much, Kelly -- I've been hoping that someone would isolate and make available Kristen Vigard's version of "God Give Me Strength" since . . . well, since the soundtrack was released.
blog comments powered by Disqus