TV Review: American Masters, “LENNONYC” (PBS)

Ken Shane November 30, 2010 3

LENNONYCI don’t know about you, but 30 years after his death the mere sound of John Lennon’s voice is still enough to fill me with emotion. An enormous talent was lost to the world on that long ago December night, and more than that a powerful voice for peace was silenced.

I’ve watched most of the Lennon documentaries, and some of them are very good indeed. The problem that they all have, and the new PBS entry LENNONYC is no exception, is that they all have the same terrible ending. You see it coming, you know it’s coming, from the first frame. It’s like a runaway train that’s coming right at you. You’re powerless to stop it.

I would imagine that the story of the Beatles is among the most widely covered stories of the 20th century. There is very little that is not known about the band members, individually and collectively. The most that anyone can hope for from a new article, book, or film about the Beatles is that it will shed a little light on some less-covered aspect of their story. Still, the coverage keeps coming, and that is because we never seem to tire of the subject. Each season seems to bring a new book or film, and in the case of PBS, there are two new films, the other a dramatization called Lennon, Naked.

I’m pleased to report that LENNONYC does manage to provide a fascinating look at that period of John Lennon’s life that began with his move to New York City in 1971, and concluded with his death there nine years later. We learn about his early New York City days, living on Bank Street in Greenwich Village, aligning himself with anti-war activists like Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin, and making music with Village favorites Elephant’s Memory. Those days are followed by Lennon’s exile and subsequent “lost weekend” in Los Angeles. Eventually he returned to New York City where Elton John invited him to appear on stage at Madison Square Garden. Yoko was there that night, and the couple reconciled. Lennon then spent several years out of the music business, raising his son Sean in the Dakota, before returning with Double Fantasy in 1980, shortly before he died.

Of course Lennon was creating indelible music throughout this period, and those efforts are documented here, as is his struggle with the US government to avoid deportation. Along the way we get commentary from people who where there, including Yoko, May Pang, Lennon confidant Elliot Mintz, photographer Bob Gruen, and record producer Jack Douglas. There are also clips from Lennon interviews, and previously unheard audio talkback from various recording sessions including some madness with Phil Spector during the Rock ‘N’ Roll sessions.

LENNONYC was written, produced, and directed by Michael Epstein, and it provides a vivid look at John Lennon’s post-Beatles life. If you missed it on PBS last week, it will certainly be repeated. In the meantime, you can watch it online at PBS, or pre-order the DVD, which will be released on December 7.

  • Anonymous

    I completely and thoroughly enjoyed “LENNONNYC”. I enjoy hearing/seeing any band/musician in the studio working their craft, seeing/hearing what goes into the masterpiece. It gave me CHILLS to hear John Lennon in the studio recording, as his inspiration flowed…and when it didn’t. This is something no Lennon fan, or music fan for that matter, should miss. Ken, you capture the points succinctly and perfectly.

  • http://thevitaminkid.blogspot.com autodidact

    It was interesting to me, especially the studio musicians and clips from studio takes. I generally don’t get excited about demos, but over the closing credits, John plays an early unplugged version of Watching The Wheels that sounds almost country. Amazing how that song changed in the studio as it got developed.

    Given Yoko’s participation, I am assuming she had a heavy hand of control in this presentation. Hence, I take a lot of it with a grain of salt. I’m not a fan of Lennon’s solo work prior to Double Fantasy. It wasn’t bad, but it didn’t have that certain special something. I think competing with Paul and George definitely had a stimulative effect in the Beatles days.

    Good for an online viewing or a rental.

  • JonCummings

    Ironically, I found the most interesting part to be the section about the “Lost Weekend” — hearing the studio outtakes with Spector, seeing the photo of John & Paul circa ’74 that doesn’t circulate much, getting the stories about the clubbing from various perspectives, etc.

    Two telltale signs that Yoko had a large measure of editorial control: First, there was no mention whatsoever of Yoko’s daughter Kyoto and the years-long custody battle with Yoko’s first husband Tony Cox, which involved numerous disappearances/kidnapings — and was ostensibly the reason J&Y came to the US in the first place, and the main rationale John used to keep getting his temporary visas extended while Nixon/Hoover tried to give him the boot. Second, there was very little discussion of the extensive role that psychics, astrologers and other assorted loonies played in J&Y’s life during the Dakota years — just a mention of the woman who charted good & bad days for them to travel.

    I agree that the audio from the studio sessions was enthralling — particularly the Double Fantasy sessions. And the stuff about the ’72 radicalism was much more extensive than anything we’d seen before, even in “The US vs. John Lennon.” Still, as good as this one is, I inevitably find all these Lennon docs (including “Imagine: John Lennon”) less riveting, or educational, than merely going back and re-reading John’s 1970 Rolling Stone interview or 1980 Playboy interview.