Unsolicited Career Advice for … Whitney Houston

Rob Smith December 14, 2009 9

This recent missive to Clive Davis, major label majordomo and Svengali to the Adult Contemporary set, discusses Uncle Donnie’s ideas for a post-comeback Whitney Houston comeback. Whether Clive or Whitney do anything with his advice is another matter entirely.

This is the last Uncle Donnie memo to be posted in 2009. On behalf of Lev and his uncle, I wish you a happy holiday. See you next year. – RS

TO: Clive Davis
FROM: Don Skwatzenschitz
RE: Career Advice for Whitney

Shalom! And a great big Gut Yontiff to you and yours! I hope it’s been a great year for you, what with Kelly coming back into the fold (is she putting on weight for a role? Did some studio finally option the script I did for From Justin to Kelly II: Alexa’s Revenge? I’ll have to check). Getting Whitney out there was a feat of pure chutzpa, as well, though her televised performances left something to—well, let’s just say they had me wishing I could see Bobby Brown scoop poo out of her toochis.

But what can you do, Clive? What can you do? You tried everything—you marketed it perfectly, you got her in the studio with passable songs and half-decent production. There were poppy/dancy tracks and big, melisma-showcasing ballads. She used to knock that stuff out of the park. Maybe she just doesn’t have it anymore. I know, I know—it’s hard to believe, much less have to face yourself, that your little doll, your female side personified for the last 25 years, has turned into a whacked-out, coked-out has-been who can’t hit the high notes anymore. It’s tough to write that, my friend. I imagine it’s even tougher to live it.

I do, however, have an idea that will help you set Whitney up for the foreseeable future—another Christmas album! One Wish was good, but very traditional. Too traditional, if you ask me (and I know you didn’t, but trust me—no one needs another “Christmas Song” or “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas”). What you need are unexpected gems that she can cover, Whitnify, if you will. Things that no one in a million years would expect her to even know about, much less record. I happen to have quite the collection of Christmas songs (I know, what’s a good Jewish boy like Albert Skwatzenschitz’s son doing with a Christmas song collection? It so happens my family celebrated both Hanukkah and Christmas. We were more confused than observant). Here are five tracks you simply must have her record:

  • “It Never Snows in L.A.” In rock and roll, the road can be a fickle mistress (not that I would know what a fickle mistress was like—Mitzi is fickle enough for ten men to deal with). Once, I was compelled to spend the winter in Hollywood, working the second Ratt album to country stations (don’t ask), and I recalled this wonderful ditty by the young but worldly Jimmy Osmond. Whitney’s world-weariness would lend some gravitas to this otherwise poppy tune.
  • “My Christmas Card to You.” Why record “Joy to the World,” when she could put pure joy to tape (or hard drive, or whatever) with this classic, originally recorded by a family of Partridges?
  • “Listen, the Snow Is Falling.” Yoko Ono—so underrated. Imagine Whitney wrapping her voice around this one. I even have a bit of orchestration in my head that might work. I’ll hum it into a USB mic and send you an MP3.
  • “Jolly Man.” Kanye did that Autotune record, and it was a huge hit, right? Well, this Zach Curd track would be a great way for Whitney to get into some of that Autotune action. And you wouldn’t have to worry about the high notes, either.
  • “Snoopy’s Christmas.” Totally left field, I know, but it falls in the great tradition of story-songs, and Whitney could use a story other than her own to discuss next time she does Oprah.

Consider these, and I’ll give you a call after the new year. Be well, my friend.

All the best,
Don

  • Pingback: Whitney Houston @fanpixie - Unsolicited Career Advice for … Whitney Houston

  • jonnythefriendlylawyer

    Is it just me, or are these UCAfor… posts NEVER funny?

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    If you never find them funny, why do you always fall for reading them?

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    On a serious note, the big Whitney comeback plan had a huge flaw. Every celebrity of recent note knows you have to cap your scandal with a big old, drippy apology. Dropping Houston back into her career's timeline without some bald-faced addressing of lost time, and what went on during those missing years, denies a segment of the public what they're looking for: total schadenfreude.

    Also, whoever shepherded this project also neglected those obviously lost years, for if they had taken them into account, they would have zeroed in on Whitney's remaining strengths versus writing for her lost ones. The high notes are gone, her voice is a tad rougher than it used to be. Go with that, don't shove her back into songs that will make her look immediately faded.

    If Clive Davis was, in fact, the guy pulling those strings, he needs to step down. He's lost touch with what is really there before him.

  • jb

    I don't read them. I love Popdose and read most of the music stuff but, when I see another one of these, I skip it. They're so unfunny and below the generally very high standard of PD content that I wonder if I'm alone in thinking that or if other regular readers agree that this column should be shitcanned. Just don't get off on the kicking of easy-target has-beens when they've been down for years and aren't getting back up.

  • mjheyliger

    The funny thing about this is-Clive and Whitney pulled this comeback off. Lack of Grammy nominations notwithstanding-”I Look to You” is a fairly strong album (possibly the best contemporary R&B album made by a female artist this year…at least until Alicia Keys' album comes out tomorrow), and it's sold close to a million copies in 3 1/2 months, which, last time I checked, less than 20 albums released in 2009 have done. And they did it without the support of pop radio. All things considered, I'd say that's pretty impressive. Was this plan executed flawlessly? No, but I don't think Whitney necessarily needs career advice when her career's no longer in trouble. Will she ever sell “Bodyguard” albums again? No. But who will? Qualitatively speaking, “I Look to You” beats the pants off of anything Whitney recorded during her heyday, even if it sells less.

    And I've gotta say, I agree with jb re: his assessment of this column.

  • EightE1

    Back when I worked in customer service there were times when a customer lodged a complaint that might or might not have been valid, but the way in which they expressed their complaint made me truly not care one way or another whether or how it got resolved. When this happened, my first response was always, “I'm sorry you feel that way.”

    I typically refrain from response when people post negative things about a given column, unless I think I've been misunderstood, or unless the reader makes a good point or one that bears further discussion or debate. I have a pretty thick skin about such things, and I'm the first one to tell ya not every post is gold. But I think plenty of them are good enough to post on a Web site with an international readership, surrounded by other writing of very high quality; I wouldn't post them if I didn't think they were.

    Popdose is a great safe haven where we editors are given the space to let our freak flags fly, vent our spleens, give voice to our inner snark organs, and try new things and new voices. Publications like this one are rare, and I am grateful for the place I have found with these talented, like-minded writers.

    So Jonny and JB, if you don't like this UCA because you don't think it's funny or worth reading, fine — opinions are great and I respectfully disagree with yours. I happen to think it's kinda cool to post a piece containing music from Jimmy Osmond, Yoko Ono, and Zach Curd. You didn't care for it — that happens; you can't please everyone.

    However, you apparently never care for the column, yet you've taken the opportunity to call for its “shitcanning.” And for that, I have to say, “I'm sorry you feel that way.”

  • jb

    Snarkiness is fine. Freakiness is fine, too. Debate about the relative merits of a given work is great. Taking a shot at an overblown ego or unreasonably popular crap is fair game. Popdose IS a great resource because it has all these things. I rarely post comments but when I do they're generally to compliment something — be it writing about new music I'm happy to discover (or rediscover) or just a well-expressed opinion. I don't always like the music that's referenced in the posts but I appreciate that other people might and that everything has value to someone. My gripe with the UCA column is that it doesn't further what Popdose is famous for: the thoughtful analysis of pop music. Popdose can come down hard on some artists but it's respectful of them and of its readers. I don't care for Whitney Houston, Tupac, Steven Tyler, etc. but I don't get a kick out of ridiculing them. UCA seems like an exercise in negativity for its own sake, which I don't consider a virtue. (I might if it was as funny as I guess it's supposed to be, but it isn't.)

  • http://www.jobsindubai.com/ Emirates Jobs

    I just love her voice for it is so unique and I thin no one can ever sing her songs perfectly the way she did