White Label Friday: Duran Duran, “Hold Back the Rain”

David Medsker February 29, 2008 12

whitelabel.gifIf you know me, then you know that I loves me some Duran Duran. Even when they make an album as unlistenable as Liberty, Pop Trash or Red Carpet Massacre — you’d be wise to not get me started on how they let a 25-year-old “producer” positively manhandle them — I will be first in line when their next record drops. I will also be using this space in the near future to pimp my all-time favorite remix, which happens to be of a well-known ballad by the boys from Birmingham. But first, let’s go to the carnival.

When the band turned Rio in to the record company, Capitol knew they had a big hit on their hands. Still, they were not taking any chances; in an attempt to wash away any lingering stench of New Romanticism, the label hired David Kershenbaum to remix various Rio tracks, with the apparent goal of making the band both club darlings and “tough” enough for rock radio. The remix EP, titled Carnival, was not only a hit in the clubs but actually cracked the album charts, and subsequent versions of Rio included Kershenbaum’s remixes in place of the band’s original versions.

Finding those mixes on CD, however, is easier said than done.

You’ll have to hunt down the import CD single for “Rio” to find Kershenbaum’s mix of “My Own Way,” while his mix of “Lonely in Your Nightmare” has inexplicably never been issued on CD. And then there is his fantastic guitar-heavy seven-minute mix of “Hold Back the Rain.” It had gone missing for years, but was finally unearthed for the blink-and-you-missed-it Night Versions: The Essential Duran Duran CD in March 1998, only to be taken out of print six months later.

I didn’t blink.

So here you go, cassette-owning Rio fans. Here is Kershenbaum’s mix of “Hold Back the Rain” (download) in all its glory. According to Wikipedia, the song is about bassist John Taylor’s growing drug problems, though I don’t see a single lyric that would support that. I can see “Lonely in Your Nightmare” being about John and drugs, but not this. And besides, what a downer association that is to make with such a kick-ass song.

  • JohnHughes

    Awesome – it also made the Singles Box Set V. 1 – is that out of print now, too?

    EDIT – Just compared them – they are different!

  • http://www.bullz-eye.com DavidMedsker

    That's the thing, there are a ton of mixes of this song, but this version — the best, in my opinion — is the only one that's out of print. The one on Strange Behavior is the most similar (probably the same as the one on Singles), but it doesn't have the same punch. Sigh.

  • thirtyhelens

    I've had this mix on MP3 for a while now… where did I get it?! I hardly ever listen to the CD mix, it's cack by comparison…(sorry, lads)

  • http://retro-remixes.blogspot.com deltablues2

    Ahh, the infamous what's-his-name mixes. How many Duranies don't even know these songs were switched around ? Wouldn't it be lovely if someone who knew about DD than me could compile the actual original versions as well as the remixed ones ? Ahem !

    The Wiki article does shed some light on the subject so at least people have an idea of which versions are where.

  • http://www.switchpod.com/cats.php?a=622 derek…

    hi,

    thanks for that!

    if people want to know about all the various versions of RIO, they should go look here:

    http://www.ionpool.net/duran/rio.html

  • Jim

    Jeez, 14(!) versions of Rio? Crazy.

    Thanks, David!

  • http://retro-remixes.blogspot.com deltablues2

    Thanks for that link. I might be able to put together some of those different versions if I could ever find them all.

  • jackdelrio

    is this link still valid? firefox says error opening file? please help!

  • http://www.bullz-eye.com DavidMedsker

    Sorry, links expire after seven days. Popdose rule. :(

    Hey, are you the coach of the Carolina Panthers?

  • Uptight Brit

    I like the cut of your jib my boy. You's got you some good taste. If you can find yourself some of DD's old stuff, check out some B-sides like “Faster than Light” and “Secret Oktober” (sic). Nice posting btw.

  • Uptight Brit

    I like the cut of your jib my boy. You's got you some good taste. If you can find yourself some of DD's old stuff, check out some B-sides like “Faster than Light” and “Secret Oktober” (sic). Nice posting btw.

  • Uptight Brit

    I like the cut of your jib my boy. You's got you some good taste. If you can find yourself some of DD's old stuff, check out some B-sides like “Faster than Light” and “Secret Oktober” (sic). Nice posting btw.