CD Review: Daft Punk, “Tron: Legacy” Soundtrack

Dw. Dunphy November 24, 2010 8

The movie Tron: Legacy arrives at a point of very good fortune, and it is the most unlikely of comebacks. First off, it’s a sequel that never should have happened. In its original release in the early-1980′s, it was a bona fide flop, the target of critical lambasting for a near incomprehensible, geek-speak  script. Yet the film struck a chord with a small but loyal few, and when CG visual effects overtook all other processes, it became something of a historical precedent (although in truth, there are very few instances of computer graphics in the movie. A lot of the visuals are standard animations backlit to have a synthetic look).

The original soundtrack for the first film was by Wendy Carlos, of Switched On Bach fame. Unlike electronic soundtracks of the time from Giorgio Moroder (Midnight Express), Vangelis and Tangerine Dream, Carlos’ mission was to create a score that was made via synth but had the layers of an orchestral composition. It stood out, but at the same time was jarring. It was another strike against the original Tron. But here we are in 2010 awaiting the sequel, shot in dedicated 3-D (as opposed to 3-D conversion after the fact), featuring original actors Bruce Boxleitner and newly-minted Oscar winner Jeff Bridges (for his role in Crazy Heart) in two roles, as Kevin Flynn and as his renegade program Clu. Thanks to technology developed for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, audiences will see Bridges as his alter-ego as he looked back in the ’80s.

And by now, you’re wondering why I haven’t mentioned the soundtrack by the electronic duo Daft Punk. The real reason is because, if you’re expecting the Tron Legacy soundtrack to be the latest album from Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo and Thomas Bangalter, you’ll be a bit disappointed. I have no doubt they were the driving force behind some of the themes, specifically a motif of descending notes that figures heavily in the score, but the overall soundtrack is predominantly orchestral with Daft Punk adding electronic touches within arrangements.

Occasionally they do break out with tracks to themselves like “Derezzed,” “Tron Legacy End Titles,” and the track that accompanies their cameo in the film, “End Of Line,” but mostly, they play as a component of the orchestra, not as the orchestra unto themselves.

This is not a bad thing actually, and while the score overall doesn’t have the weight and addictive qualities Hans Zimmer’s score for Inception had, itself an orchestral/electronic hybrid, it remains a very enjoyable piece of movie music, and succeeds where Wendy Carlos’ early entry didn’t. In movie music, there are just some scenes that require the depth of feeling an orchestrated score provides. It’s mostly a state of pop culture conditioning propagated by John Williams and his innate understanding of Wagnerian storytelling. By now, isolated synth beats and beds just don’t convey the same information as efficiently, which is where Carlos fell down on the original Tron. One could say Daft Punk have hedged their bet here, but it works. The cynic in me expects a full Daft Punk version to emerge if the film does well, but that’s something only time will reveal. For this suddenly revitalized, and increasingly lucky franchise, very little is impossible.

  • http://www.popdose.com Ted

    Thanks to David Medsker, I’m enjoying this soundtrack. You’re right about Daft Punk being mostly MIA on this soundtrack, but overall I think it conveys the right emotions of the film. Well, at least the tone I’ve derived from the trailers I’ve seen.

  • Kyle Cyr7

    Really disappointed at the soundtrack as said most of the tracks where daft adding buts and pieces. only 3 Good songs and the only PERFECT song is Derezzed which was the only song that actually had a little daft punk spunk in it. The Soundtrack is what it is don’t expect it to be a full fledged Daft CD

  • Nick

    Listened soundtrack at Spotify premium and as an “old schooler” i’d got quite bit disappointed with score. There is no “originality” with this score..you can hear a lot Batman Dark Knight and some Matrix Reloaded / Trinity stylish themes, expect specific Daft Punk tunes.
    Verdict? Daft Punk makes really great music to the dance floor and the house partys, but movies?. Not convinced. Tron Legacy should deserved more =/ Sorry!

    Ps.I bet Jack Wall would done better.

    Pss. I will definitely go watch the movie…maybe the music will get better at the big screen. ;)

  • Callisto

    OMG, this is a movie soundtrack, not a techno album. How stupid people are out there?

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    In their defense, Disney did very little to dissuade that impression, going so far as to only release the clips that featured Daft Punk, and clamping down on the rest of the details. I only hope that was the only spin they’ve put on the movie, otherwise it’s going to be a long two hours.

  • MagnumX

    I find the entire review offensive. Tron did not have “conventional’ animation back-lighted. It had people being FILMED backlighted. And it had 3D animation all over the place (light-cycles, solar-sailer scenes, Zark’s carrier used throughout the movie, the MCP, the title intro, the transition to the electronic world, the disc/contact with Alan 1, the confrontation with the MCP…. Whomever reviewed this movie was an IDIOT. Then he disrespects the original soundtrack as a “strike”? Is the reviewer some Generation WHY kid who grew up on techno or what? Tron had one of the BEST and most iconic soundtracks of all time. It is as important to that movie as the visual effects. Having John Williams put Star Wars or Indiana Jones music in there would not only be stupid, but catastrophic to the movie and from what I’ve heard of the new Legacy soundtrack so far it’s just another case of trying to pick some popular band to do something because they’re popular instead of unique and then throw in some traditional scoring (Tron isn’t supposed to be traditional; it’s not Indiana Jones for goodness sake).

    Despite “flop” status, the original Tron movie was one of my favorites growing up and it still is with its ahead of its time concepts that actually precepted the movie The Matrix with religious overtones and questions about “what is reality”. Only someone with tastes for cheap box office thrills like Terminator and Rocky would call the first movie an incomprehensible geek-speak script. Guess what genius? It’s your mind that is too slow to recognize the brilliance of a movie for its time and to appreciate the best combination of analog synth and orchestra ever done. Expecting a Techno album in a soundtrack is like wanting rock music in a Conan The Barbarian movie (yes they wanted to do that too). It doesn’t feel right and it does’t work. Just compare the soundtracks (and the movie) of Conan The Barbarian to Kull The Conqueror to see what I mean. The latter feels more like Bill & Ted.

  • Visor

    Couldn’t agree more (well, except for calling Terminator and Rocky “cheap box office thrills”, but that’s a completely different topic). 
     
    DwDunphy really needs to watch the 90-minute documentary of The Making of Tron on the 20th anniversary DVD (I believe it was also included on the new Blu-ray version).  A LOT of CGI work went into the original film, and pushed the the CGI companies into areas they’d never been before.
     
    Also, how could he deem the original story “nearly incomprehensible geek-speak”?  It’s not like the characters were talking in Assembly language throughout the movie.  The story was simple: The evil and corrupt Ed Dillenger stole the code for all of Kevin Flynn’s videogames, and put Flynn on a quest for the evidence to nail Dillenger to the wall.  How common has a story like that been in the headlines in these modern times?  Meanwhile, Tron was a time of mainframes, so the story is even simpler in that there was only ONE system to deal with.
     
    Wendy Carlos’ soundtrack was wonderful.  Listen to “Miracle and Magician”, where Flynn resurrects a Recognizer.  The piece perfectly melds synth and full orchestra, building up to a beautiful climax as the Recognizer is fully reassembled.
     
    Lastly, the film was not a “bona fide flop”.  It had a 17 million dollar budget and grossed 33 million in the U.S. alone.  Pretty darn good considering E.T. was sucking up all the summer cash that year.  Please do your homework before trying to make yourself look cool by “lambasting” a successful film.

  • Visor

    Sorry, this was meant to be a reply to MagnumX’s post.  When I say, “Couldn’t agree more”, I’m agreeing with MagnumX, NOT DwDunphy.