Greatest Un-Hits: Yoko Ono’s “Walking on Thin Ice” (1981)

Brian Boone March 9, 2011 7

This column usually presents semi-obscure or forgotten songs that should have been hits. “Walking on Thin Ice” is different, because if you’re the kind of person with an obsessive enough interest in music to read a site like Popdose, then you’re certainly very familiar with “Walking on Thin Ice,” the best known song by rock’s biggest villain. But this catchy, haunting little piece of post-disco bears examination 30 years on, as it holds up as one of the brainier, darker, and weirder songs from a genre noted for its cheese and disposability.

“Walking on Thin Ice” was released as a single just a few weeks after the shocking murder of John Lennon, Ono’s husband and the song’s co-producer. (He also provided the crazy-weird guitar hooks for what was one of the last songs he ever worked on.) Despite the international mourning period for Lennon, the song couldn’t reach higher than #58 on the Hot 100, the only song Ono ever charted there. Such is the lingering, undying hatred for Ono for “breaking up the Beatles.” (She didn’t, of course. You know it. I know it. Evolve.)

However, the song was eventually redeemed, sort of. A remix of the song went to #1 on the Dance chart in 2003.

 

  • http://www.discoskonfort.com/artists/drxl/ Anonymous

    “a genre noted for its cheese and disposability.”? I hope you do not mean disco music

  • javajoelmurphy

    Wasnt this the song that Lennon & Yoko were working on the night John got shot?

  • Brian Boone

    Javajoel – They’d been working on it the weekend before his death. He reportedly had a mix of the song on his person at the time.

  • http://genxsingalong.wordpress.com Gigi

    I love this song and own the maxi-single of remixes. Listen to it regularly. Testify.

  • Anonymous

    I have to admit I secretly like Fuzzbox’s version of this song they have on their ‘Big Bang’ album… ;)

  • http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_songs-Power-Pop.html Brett Alan

    I’m a big fan of Yoko’s music, but even if there had been no sentiment against her it would have faced a tough road to commercial success. Her singing was never very commercial, and a lot of her music was very non-commercial. Sonic Youth didn’t have any hits, either. She was so ahead of her time that her own musicians didn’t understand her…I saw a bunch of her live shows around the time of Rising, with a young band led by Sean, and the old songs worked better than they did with John and the people he was working with.

    Yoko has now had *eight* number one hits on the dance chart. All in her seventies, I believe (although most are remixes of earlier work). That puts her I believe tied for 12th all-time on the chart, ahead of the likes of Ultra Nate, Britney Spears, Chaka Kahn, Crystal Waters, Justin Timberlake, and New Order. Pretty amazing.

    I see there’s a tag for Elvis Costello, but no mention of his cover version, so here you go. B^)

  • keith

    I was surprised when reading the recent Rolling Stone: “The Last Lennon Interview” how involved John was with this track right up until the moment he was shot. Every December, all those sad, angry emotions boil to the surface, only to be cooled slightly by this great, sinister, new wave dance song – on headsets it sounds as modern today as current hipster disco tracks.