Basement Songs: Billy Joel, “And So It Goes”

Maybe it’s the fall, or the fact that I’m missing the fall, but every September my heart starts to feel the season change as if it were turning from blood red to golden orange and yellow, like the trees I recall from my youth.

During these months I can’t help but think of my close friend Bob. Ours is a friendship that’s grown into one of the tightest relationships I have. I was the best man in his first wedding, an honor I still hold close to my heart even though that relationship didn’t last. That wedding took place in late summer, 1991, just after I returned from my first California adventure. While I’m not an ardent Billy Joel fan, “And So It Goes” is a reminder of that time in his life, and it conjures images of Bob’s strength against the punches life threw at him when things fell apart.

Bob and I met during my freshman year at Bowling Green; he was the pledge trainer in my fraternity. Since it was the band fraternity, I didn’t take the organization too seriously; I was a cocky freshman who thought he was much better than those other band geeks. Thankfully, I learned what a fool I was, as the men in that fraternity became my best friends. Bob and I wound up living next to each other during my sophomore year; that was the point when things changed, and we began to turn to each other for advice, encouragement, and beer. Throughout the remainder of my college years, whenever Bob came to Bowling Green for a visit, he was sure to stop by our house and hang out, maybe even crash for the night.

On one of those visits, he proposed to his girlfriend in the stadium seats as a BG football game was played in the background. It was a great romantic gesture, one that is as clear to me today as the heat coming from the sun on that afternoon. Soon thereafter, he asked me to be his best man and honestly, I had no clue what I was supposed to do. Still, I stood by his side and watched as they exchanged vows. When they moved into their first apartment, I was a frequent visitor and considered it a safe haven away from home.

Sadly, the marriage did not last. I feared for Bob and what the divorce would do to him. Would he be incredibly pissed? Would he be sad beyond consolation? I wasn’t sure. To make matters worse, when his marriage ended, Julie and I were already living in California, so the best I could do is be a voice on the other end of the telephone. Helpless, that’s how I felt. And yet, Bob seemed to pull through okay. He would fall in love again; he would accomplish great things in his life, and he would continue to be a stand-up guy.

In my office hangs a picture Bob took at Yosemite, a photograph of a waterfall in black and white. Something about that image is so profound, yet in its two tones, also very melancholy. When I stare at that image long enough, I begin to hear this song from Billy Joel’s album Storm Front. The last time I saw Bob was this past July. We caught up with our other college friends, Dan and Brad. All four of us have had some rough times and seemed to come out on the other side okay. Coincidentally, I saw Billy Joel on the Storm Front tour with Dan and Brad. While our excursion to Detroit and quick jaunt into Canada (for the hell of it) is a great memory, it’s Bob who comes to mind when those first chords of “And So It Goes” come through the speakers. It could be the fact that I missing the fall or that I’m missing the leaves changing colors, but the truth is, I’m missing my friend and wishing the best for him.

Tags: , ,

  • This is a really fantastic post. It moved me to listen to this song which I have not done in ages. For me, the marriage of music with the personal makes for some of the most compelling stories. Kudos.
  • Bob B
    Incredibly Scotty, that day you stood by my side was seventeen years ago this Sunday. How that is possible?!?!? I have no idea. I have lived seemingly many lifetimes in these past seventeen years, but it also seems like just yesterday when you and I (and the countless others that came to our rooms) sat waxing poetics, having great times and complaining about the "problems" that BG and/or life had presented us back then. Oh, to only have THOSE problems again! It is somewhat ironic that you picked this song/subject when you did, for I have had a feeling of "fall remorse" this year that I haven't experienced in well over a decade. I have had many new people come into my life over the past seventeen years, some have stayed briefly, some have remained as new constants, but none, and I mean none, have or will ever measure to your standards as a friend, or really, the brother you have become to me. Thank you for always being you, nothing more could I ever ask.
  • Malchus
    Wow, one of the nicest comments I've ever received.
  • Amy Sprague
    Scott,

    This is one of those songs that grow more poignant with experiences. When this song came out my parents just announced they were divorcing after 21 years of marriage. To this day I cannot listen to it without thinking back to that time. But it does not remind me of my sadness, but of the sadness both my parents must have felt. Sadness I could not relate to as a 21 year old in a great new relationship. But it is sadness that became all too real when Phil and I hit a rough patch 7 years into our own marriage. I always wonder if Joel was talking about the demise of his own marriage because those words are from the heart of and not the strict product of a songwriter.
  • Malchus
    From what I've read, he wrote the song in 1983 about the demise of his first marriage.
  • If I'm remembering right, he actually wrote it after his divorce, and it was about being dumped by a supermodel. Or dating one, and anticipating being dumped. (Not Christie.)
  • Malchus
    Could be. I just looked it up on the extensive Billy Joel Wiki pages. But, you know how reliable those can be. You're a better authority on Joel than I am, senor.
  • You've written some incredibly powerful posts, Scott. And because of that, I feel comfortable sharing this phenomenally embarrassing story with the rest of the class.

    I met someone for a date one August day in 1997 (it was actually the Sunday after Princess Diana died) and we eventually made it back to my place to fool around a little. This song came on the radio as we were...uh doing whatever and for some reason I started to cry...during sex. With someone who I had only been on one date with. Incredibly, we continued dating for about six months after that and are still very good friends today. Come to think about it, maybe I should cry more often during sex.
  • Nice one with good content.Music is a part of our lives almost every day. Even if we do not consider ourself to be a big music fan, we stillunconsciously listen to music everyday.
  • Jacquie M
    ...I am in tears and at a loss for words.....
blog comments powered by Disqus