The Fourth Day of Mellowmas: Spektormas

Jeff Giles and Jason Hare December 4, 2010 43

Before we kick off today’s round of exquisite Mellowmas torture, how about some discount music and a contest? Our friends at Rhino are celebrating the Twelve Days of Chri — er, Rhino, and for the fourth day, they’re not only offering a whopping 40% discount on Heaven & Hell’s limited edition Live from Radio City Music Hall CD/DVD set, but they’re giving away a $25 promo code to one lucky Popdose reader! Here’s what you need to do to enter:

Visit the Rhino site and find out how much you need to spend to get free shipping on your order. Then email the answer to Dw. Dunphy with the subject line “I am the Rhino contest winner.” Our winner will be chosen at random, and all entries must be received by noon PST tomorrow. Good luck!

Jason: Hey, another Christmas compilation from Warner Bros.! Gift Wrapped II: Snowed In.

Jeff: A sequel! With Roman numerals, even!

Jason: There were some good songs on Gift Wrapped – 20 Songs That Keep On Giving!

Jeff: There were? I don’t recall.

Jason: Yeah, the live Buble “Let It Snow” was good. A good version of “Silver Bells” by Meaghan Smith.

Jeff: Who’s Meaghan Smith? Never mind, I don’t care. I used to love Warner Bros. Records. Then they got rid of all their best executives in the mid ’90s.

Jason: So what does that mean for this compilation?

Jeff: Mainly that I have no idea who’s even on Warners anymore, other than the Goo Goo Dolls, who — of course! — are on this. Singing the classic carol “Better Days.”

Jason: What the hell is “Better Days”?

Jeff: Oh, wait, “Better Days” isn’t a Christmas song, it’s THEIR MOST RECENT SINGLE. And that, my friends, is Mellowmas in a nutshell. How fucking crass!

Jason: Oh. And here I was hoping it was a Citizen King cover.

Jeff: Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! That would be perfect.

Jason: And yes, I totally had to look up the song to find out who sung it.

Jeff: I want a whole album of covers like that. Mediocrity Meets Mediocrity: Covers of Songs You Barely Remember by Artists You Can’t Stand.

Jason: All by the Goo Goo Dolls?

Jeff: Train could cover, I don’t know, Stroke 9 or something.

Jason: I’ve been dying to hear the Goo’s version of “Sex and Candy.”

Jeff: snort

Jason: So what shall we listen to from this steaming pile of coal?

Jeff: We shall listen to the Regina Spektor track “December,” which was apparently recorded just for this compilation. Such a wintry title! Candy canes and hot cocoa!

Jason: Maybe it’s inspired by the George Winston album! Just Regina Spektor playing piano, barefoot. Bald and with a beard, too.

Jeff: Oh, I hope so! And not singing.

Jason: You don’t like Regina Spektor?

Jeff: Isn’t Regina Spektor something that fell off Tori Amos?

Jason: I thought it was shitty that she changed the spelling of her last name to hide that she’s Phil’s daughter.

Jeff: Well, you know. That hair is embarrassing.

Jason: After this track, that might be the least of the problems. We can hope, anyway. She was on the last Gift Wrapped compilation.

Jeff: Which I apparently have on my hard drive. The Mellowmas pain, it all blurs together.

Jason: “My Dear Acquaintance (A Happy New Year) [iTunes Live Session Performance].” I gave it three stars.

Jeff: Three stars, eh? That’s a lot to live up to.

Jason: Nah, only the four and five star songs remain on my playlists. There are helicopters on the track, which bummed me out because I thought it was going to be a “Goodnight Saigon” cover.

Jeff: Now I want to hear a holiday mix of “Goodnight Saigon.”

Jason: I think there’s already triangle or something on that song. They just need jingle bells.

Jeff: Let’s listen.

Regina Spektor — December (download)

From Gift Wrapped II: Snowed In

Jeff: Hey, this does sound like George Winston!

Jason: Out of tune George Winston, yes.

Jeff: Oh, wait, no it doesn’t. This sounds like…motion sickness.

Jason: What the fuck is this? She’s singing like she has a bunch of Big League Chew in her mouth.

Jeff: This is what Regina Spektor thinks of when she thinks of December.

Jason: “Come on and say you’re sorry, real sorry for the trouble that you caused.” Wasn’t this supposed to be on Warner Bros’ Yom Kippur compilation?

Jeff: I think she stole this melody from an ancient Hebrew song. “We ah not evacuatin’ this ‘ouse!”

Jason: Ha ha ha ha! “We don’t believe you, we don’t believe in you.”

Jeff: Who does she not believe in? I’m not understanding this at all. Is she talking to Santa?

Jason: I think she does not believe in pitch. She also does not believe in happiness.

Jeff: Or actual time signatures. Oh, thank God. It’s over.

Jason: Wow, that was quick.

Jeff: DON’T COMPLAIN. I think that was something she made up on the spot in a single take.

Jason: I’m not complaining. Actually, what I’m doing is picturing the Warner Bros. execs’ faces when they received this track for the compilation.

Jeff: Ha!

Jason: “GOD DAMMIT, REGINA, JUST FUCKING SING ‘SANTA CLAUS IS COMING TO TOWN.”

Jeff: Lots of pinched nose bridges, I imagine. Imagine actually being snowed in with Regina Spektor?

Jason: No. I won’t do it.

Jeff: I think by night one, I’d start trying to convince everyone else that we needed to eat her to survive.

Jason: cackle
I’ve taken to looking up meanings of this song on the Internet.

Jeff: There’s stuff about this song on the Internet?

Jason: Yup.

Jeff: I assumed you’d send me a link to http://whyreginaspektorwhy.com.

Jason: “This song is beautiful, then again..what song of her’s isn’t beautiful?” The spelling isn’t the only thing wrong with that statement.

Jeff: I’m just blinking in silence.

Jason: There are 37 comments on the meaning of this song. And not one of them is “First!”

Jeff: To quote our friend Billy K. Harmony, I hate this world.

Jason: “The second verse is God trying to talk to the human. He’s telling the human and all of human race to apologize for all the war and hate they brought to the world, along with all the sin and stuff. He’s asking how they don’t see all his love for them and the world.”

Jeff: “Along with all the sin and stuff.” What the hell?

Jason: THIS SONG IS ON A FUCKING CHRISTMAS COMPILATION

Jeff: Yeah, and it’s like two minutes long!

Jason: I can’t wait until 2011, when Judy Collins and Regina Spektor do their long-awaited collaboration. Wait, here’s another comment: “The final verse baffles me. Why does she start singing like a ruddy old Cockney? Is that how we sound to God, when we cling on to our houses in the face of ‘You and Your wrecking crew’? ”

I’ll take this one, Jeff. THE REASON SHE SOUNDS LIKE A RUDDY OLD COCKNEY IS BECAUSE SHE’S AN ASSHOLE.

Jeff: “A ruddy old Cockney”! Ha! Oh, wait, I know!

Jason: Lay it on me.

Jeff: It’s because this song is being sung from the perspective of Dick Van Dyke’s character in “Mary Poppins.” THE END. And you know what? Regina Spektor is fucking insane, so I lay even odds that my interpretation is the right one.

Jason: Are you sure? Because I have another interpretation.

Jeff: Go on.

Jason: If the Sabbath is the depths of winter, that suggests a profound bleakness attached to spirituality, maybe newfound atheism. To lose your religion would ‘turn your down upside’ – cause your darkness to surface. To find you have fallen out of love with the Creator is painfully captured in those lines about rumours of romance, where any playful tone is overtly and deliberately disowned by the singer.

Jeff: taps screen

Jason: What, that doesn’t make sense to you? Because it SURE MAKES SENSE TO ME. SHUT UP INTERNET

Jeff: Hold on, I’m busy forging power of attorney so I can have you committed.

Jason: I want to send every one of these commenters a copy of Fred Schneider’s “Fruitcake.”

Jeff: I feel like they’re already living it. Although it might be fun to watch them try to analyze it.

Jason: This is a truly awful track. And you suggested it for Mellowmas.

Jeff: Naturally.

Jason: …Thank you, old friend.

Jeff: Well, it’s like I said going in. This is the meaning of Mellowmas.

Jason: I can’t remember anything before Regina Spektor’s out-of-tune piano. If you said that, I’ll have to take your word for it.

Jeff: And if I ever meet Regina Spektor, I’m totally cow-punching her in the uterus. Note: I don’t know what a cow-punch is. I just made that up. But it makes as much sense as anything in “December.”

Jason: I think if you cow-punched her, it would speak to how the world has fallen down around us, and maybe the pain of a broken home has overtaken everything we know about the holiday spirit. And then something about the Sabbath, too. I don’t know if that last sentence makes sense. I just quickly threw together a bunch of words.

Jeff: And a melody that sounds like a broken shofar’s horn.

Jason: It made as much sense to me as anything else I’ve heard today. Thanks for ruining Christmas, Regina Spektor!

Jeff: applause

Jason: Or should I say REGINA SPECTOR.
Wait a minute.
Hold on.
Remember one of those lyrics?
“We don’t believe in you and your wrecking crew.”

Jeff: gasp

Jason: SHE’S TALKING ABOUT PHIL SPECTOR!

Jeff: Play it backwards! Play it backwards!

Jason: REGINA SPEKTOR DOESN’T BELIEVE IN HAL BLAINE! Man, Regina. What did Carol Kaye ever do to you?

Jeff: Played actual music?

Jason: I can’t believe I figured it out.

Jeff: Hey, what do you know? If you play this backwards, it turns into “My Pal Foot Foot.”

Jason: Ha ha ha ha ha ha!

  • http://twitter.com/tcote Thierry Côté

    While I’m a fan of Regina Spektor, I’m a little mystified as to what this, a song that’s been around for at least 4 years (she’s been playing it live for at least that long) that has nothing to do with Christmas – Spektor is a Russian Jew – was included on this compilation. To be fair, I’m just as mystified that it would include a 16-year-old Ben Keith track as well as a David Foster (!) instrumental between songs by current rock acts like Foxy Shazam (doing a Jesus Christ Superstar song???), Tegan & Sara, Everest and the Flaming Lips. Who’s the target audience for this? People who like random, peripherally Christmas/December-related shit?

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Four years? Funny. I’m almost positive it was listed in the “specially recorded for this compilation” part of this ‘ouse — I mean the press kit.

  • Snipnsnap

    I think this is the worst of the year. I broke my ankle a couple years ago and this was more painful. At least it was short.

  • http://www.wingsforwheels.net dslifton

    I wonder if Ted Asregadoo’s eyes glazed over as soon as you started talking about “Goodnight Saigon.”

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    Ha ha ha ha ha ha!

    You’ve been eating appetizers up to now. Wait t’il the entrees throw up – I mean, show up.

  • Pavlov’s Son

    Dissing Regina… not cool.

  • http://twitter.com/tcote Thierry Côté

    Maybe this recording is, but the song itself is not new at all – just checked on songmeanings.net and the post dates from 2005, so it’s actually at least 5 years!

  • Anonymous

    Oh, darn. Looks like that new edit of “Celebrate Christmas” took up the memory I would have used for “December”. I’m afraid my ‘ouse just doesn’t have room.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, darn. Looks like that new edit of “Celebrate Christmas” took up the memory I would have used for “December”. I’m afraid my ‘ouse just doesn’t have room.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, darn. Looks like that new edit of “Celebrate Christmas” took up the memory I would have used for “December”. I’m afraid my ‘ouse just doesn’t have room.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mburke77 Michael Burke

    There’s this whole genre of tuneless, aggressively un-catchy female fronted “music” out there designed to appeal to solely to Billyburg hipsters, and thus infuriate everyone else.

    Regina, (friend of Popdose) Joanna Newsom, Florence and the Machine, it’s all of a sort.

    Does Joanna have a Christmas album?

  • http://www.facebook.com/mburke77 Michael Burke

    There’s this whole genre of tuneless, aggressively un-catchy female fronted “music” out there designed to appeal to solely to Billyburg hipsters, and thus infuriate everyone else.

    Regina, (friend of Popdose) Joanna Newsom, Florence and the Machine, it’s all of a sort.

    Does Joanna have a Christmas album?

  • http://www.facebook.com/mburke77 Michael Burke

    There’s this whole genre of tuneless, aggressively un-catchy female fronted “music” out there designed to appeal to solely to Billyburg hipsters, and thus infuriate everyone else.

    Regina, (friend of Popdose) Joanna Newsom, Florence and the Machine, it’s all of a sort.

    Does Joanna have a Christmas album?

  • http://popdose.com Anonymous

    So your favorite artists can’t be held up to criticism, or else it’s a diss? Gotcha.

  • http://popdose.com Anonymous

    If she does, it likely has three tracks each lasting fourteen minutes, and Santa is only referred to as “Pere Noel”.

  • http://popdose.com Anonymous

    If she does, it likely has three tracks each lasting fourteen minutes, and Santa is only referred to as “Pere Noel”.

  • http://popdose.com Anonymous

    If she does, it likely has three tracks each lasting fourteen minutes, and Santa is only referred to as “Pere Noel”.

  • http://arensb.livejournal.com/ arensb

    I never thought I’d say this, and it hurts like shoving pine cones up my urethra, but that song needs some Auto-Tune.

  • http://arensb.livejournal.com/ arensb

    Should I just give up and poke out my eardrums now?

  • http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_songs-Power-Pop.html Brett Alan

    If you guys really didn’t plan the Phil Spector’s daughter joke setting up the Wrecking Crew thing, you’re absolutely brilliant. Or even if you did. I’m talking tears-in-my-eyes hysterical laughter. Thanks!

  • Marie

    SERIOUSLYWHATTHEFUCK.

  • http://www.bullz-eye.com Anonymous

    Ouch, that was dreadful. And I usually think she’s okay, in small doses.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    I promise we didn’t plan it. For the most part, we don’t even listen to the songs before we talk about them. There’s some light editing after the fact, but otherwise, these chats are free from jazz, baby. Glad you’re digging it!

  • Anonymous

    If I was “snowed in” and had to listen to that song again, I’d dig a tunnel to get out.

    I generally like Spektor too, but jesus pleezus that was dire.

  • http://www.kenshane.com kshane

    This is huge in Van Beardswick (thank you 30 Rock).

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    But we still have 21 days to go!

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Defend this song.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    We do not believe in you.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    On the plus side, it’s one of the few genres where harp makes contextual sense.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Er, free FORM jazz. I need to drink before I type.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    I haven’t listened to enough of her to have an opinion either way. I remember kind of digging her debut (or maybe it was just her American debut — it came out four years ago, I think), but I don’t remember anything else about it. Don’t we already have Kate Bush for stuff like this?

  • http://mostlymodernmedia.wordpress.com Beau

    I was so taken by the “made up on the spot” comment that I immediately pictured Dana Carvey singing “choppin’ brocco-lay-ay” during this tune. Fit perfectly.

    It’s as if she rejected modern tonality and time signatures and tried to improv a 12-tone piece but gave up a few measures into the exercise.

  • http://mostlymodernmedia.wordpress.com Beau

    I was so taken by the “made up on the spot” comment that I immediately pictured Dana Carvey singing “choppin’ brocco-lay-ay” during this tune. Fit perfectly.

    It’s as if she rejected modern tonality and time signatures and tried to improv a 12-tone piece but gave up a few measures into the exercise.

  • Foo

    Yeah, but nothing you do will top the magic of the incomparable Wng, so why torture myself?

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Define “magic.”

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    Her music saws people in half.

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    A likely story. No soup for you.

  • http://www.popdose.com DwDunphy

    Don’t drag Harry Partch into this. He never expected his ideas to be used like that.

  • http://thevitaminkid.blogspot.com autodidact

    As a paranoid Beck-ian Tea Partier, I can only interpret this marathon of Mellowmas as part of the vast left-wing conspiracy to destroy Christmas and everything that’s right about America — to associate the holy Judeo-Christian holiday times with nausea, dizziness, and piercing pains in the head (especially the ears), followed by severe depression and self-loathing. Way to go, scumbags!

    But wait a minute… as part of a Paleo-Christian sect who believes that only biblical festivals are legitimate, and that Christmas is simply a mask of Christ pasted on to a bunch of pagan winter solstice rituals/symbols with their related debaucheries (and the modern addition of empty consumerism), I think you’re unwitting warriors in a holy crusade. Way to go, friends!

    That Fred Figglehorn thing made me want to hurt myself, though. Have mercy! Or a lot of us are not gonna survive 21 days. It’s kinda like chemotherapy. Gotta dose this stuff right, or the patient may not survive…

    Your most loyal “hate-filled conservative” reader

  • Neil Cake

    So I’m thinking that at some point someone told you guys that you’re funny. Cos I’ve got news for you: you aren’t.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Oh my God, Neil, you hurt my feelings.

  • Livesitedemo

    Um. Maybe you guys should do some research before mouthing off. The song ‘December’ has been around for YEARS. It was previously released as a B-side on the Fidelity and Us EPs in the UK. Also, I think you’re being a little hard on Regina. It was Warner’s decision to include her song on the holiday compilation, although it has absolutely nothing to do with Christmas. A huge error on their part.

  • http://www.popdose.com jefito

    Ha ha ha! You said “hard on.” You totally did!