1984 was a great year for foreign-language and independent cinema in the U.S. Off the top of my head I can recall seeing the following at Chicagoâ€™s Fine Arts Theater, sadly defunct by the turn of the century: the Coen Brothersâ€™ debut, Blood Simple; Jonathan Demmeâ€™s Stop Making Sense and Rob Reinerâ€™s This is Spinal Tap; Jim Jarmuschâ€™s Stranger Than Paradise; Alan Rudolphâ€™s Choose Me; Giorgio Moroderâ€™s take on Metropolis; Ingmar Bergmanâ€™s Fanny and Alexander; Bertrand Tavernierâ€™s A Sunday in the Country. Not to mention Wim Wendersâ€™ Palme dâ€™Or winner at Cannes, Paris, Texas which as its title suggests is a mix of both strains, an English-language film made by German and French talent in the American Southwest.
But I didnâ€™t much care for Paris, Texas. In fact I remember getting into arguments about it. A typically thorough and insightful Criterion Collection DVD has made me see the error of my ways, but it also confirmed that I was right the first time.
While there is a Paris, Texas the film, written by Sam Shepard, never gets to it. (So any arthouse adventurer planning a pilgrimage is missing the point.) A photograph of a vacant lot there is one of the few possessions owned by the ragged, non-communicative Travis (Harry Dean Stanton), who has spent four years wandering the dust-dry desert of Big Bend, TX. Intriguingly, Wenders intended for Shepard to play the part, but the scribe and sometime actor was right to decline in favor of Stanton, a familiar face (fresh from the earlier cult sensation Repo Man) never more haunting than here. Travis is retrieved from his meandering by his concerned brother, Walt (Dean Stockwell, another actor trailing a long resume through mainstream and fringe productions), who piles him in his car and returns him to Los Angeles.
Itâ€™s this first, enigmatic section of the film that people most remember, for two reasons besides the silent Stanton. One is the masterful photography by Robby MÃ¼ller, not just the sun-blasted landscapes but the sinuous way his camera negotiates tight space in vehicles (a constant in the film, as Wenders notes in his commentary) and found locations like arid hotel rooms. The other is Ry Cooderâ€™s amazing slide guitar score, with a title track based on Blind Willie Johnsonâ€™s â€œDark Was the Night (Cold Was the Ground).â€ Once heard, never forgotten. I played my tape of the soundtrack until it wore out.
My recollection of the second part of Paris, Texas was fuzzier, but on rewatching turned out to be its most delightful stretch, and the reason why others recall a film I remember as somber and morose as joyous and life affirming (not in a Hollywood bear-hug way, but still). Shepard may be the author of record but the scenes where Travis reunites with his now eight-year-old son, Hunter (Hunter Carson), were largely improvised by the kid, a natural. His boyish babble is in sharp contrast to the taciturn Travis, and draws him out of his shell. It may well be that being a parent I now see how this works offscreen; itâ€™s hard to detach when a special someone is doing everything possible to engage you, and Carson, with his talk about spaceships and space shuttles, has that impish magic in spades. (His father, L.M. Kit Carson, adapted the screenplay, and he and his mother, Karen Black, starred in 1986â€™s Invaders from Mars remake.)
The third part, where a reinvigorated Travis heads to Houston to locate his wife Jane (Nastassja Kinski, blonde, Southern-accented, and more touching than I recalled), is where I got lost on the road. Back then the 145-minute film slowed to a crawl as Travis found Jane at a strange peepshow-type parlor, where the women sit behind windows in themed vignettes (coffeeshop, oceanside, etc.) and talk to the men via phone. The two scenes between the play-acting couple, who canâ€™t see each other, go on at length, and I yearned to be outside again (and wondered what Hunter, who had come along on the trip, was doing unattended). The metaphor for alienation, or disconnection, or ennui, or whatever, felt overblown, and rigidly â€œEuropeanâ€ and arty after the open-minded fascination with America typical of Wendersâ€™ work. I still donâ€™t think it succeeds and my first, negative impression counts. But thanks to Wenders I now understand how itâ€™s supposed to work, as two one-act plays inserted into the narrative, deliberately packing the movie into those airless rooms. The ending, which Wenders wrestled with, restores a measure of breathing space.
The DVD canâ€™t help but get you on the filmâ€™s wavelength, and my resistance to buying a Blu-ray player is really tested knowing this edition is also available in that format. The set has the gorgeously transferred film (1.78:1 aspect ratio, anamorphically enhanced) on one disc and a carload of well-scavenged supplements on the other, including a 1989 documentary that traces Wendersâ€™ career up to Paris, Texas; a segment from a French TV show spotlighting the director and Cooder at work on the score; a detailed Wenders interview and chats with assistants Claire Denis and Allison Anders, who now have significant careers of their own; and the battered trailer (itâ€™s hard to believe 20th Century Fox took it under its wing). The handsomely illustrated booklet collects other commentary, from the director, Shepard, and the principal actors including Stanton, who says, â€œCommunicating in silence is a powerful thing.â€
As is communicating in music. Like I said, once heard, never forgotten, even a snippetâ€¦
[kml_flashembed movie="http://www.youtube.com/v/Fbr3MDI1QLc" width="600" height="344" allowfullscreen="true" fvars="fs=1" /]