Introducing logic analysis to the storytelling and lyrics of pop songs is a dangerous thread to pull on. Especially in the music of the 1970s where you had a woman trapping her rapist in a supernatural radio (Helen Reddy “Angie Baby”), a paraplegic war veteran watching his girl go into town without him every night to be the town bicycle (Kenny Rogers “Ruby, Don’t Take Your Love To Town”), and the darkness and weird narrator logic of a teenage daughter unsuccessfully begging her dad not to kill her and her boyfriend (David Geddes “Run Joey Run”).
But there’s a pivotal turn in an iconic song that I think we all need to reckon with. It’s the plot twist in “Escape (The Pina Colada Song)” by Rupert Holmes.
Even The Main Premise Is Weird
This is one weird-ass song. A married man is more than bored with his relationship; the song is actually called “Escape” with “(The Pina Colada Song)” as just a parenthetical title.
Said narrator places a personal ad looking for an affair. This is presented as a perfectly reasonable thing to do. The song plays it as frisky and fun when in reality, it’s pretty shitty behavior.
Now, look at his personal ad itself. These are the things he wants:
- Pina coladas
- Getting caught in the rain
- Yoga
- Champagne
- Making love at midnight
At the risk of sounding too old-school, making love at midnight is really the only traditionally heterosexual thing on that list.
If you saw this personal ad would you: A) Respond, or B) Show it to your friends to make fun of it?
The Big Reveal
By the end of the second verse, the narrator and the woman he’s written to maybe twice or three times are going to meet. Where? At O’Malley’s. Why? To plan their escape!
Here comes the haymaker: The woman walks in and it turns out that the woman he’s been writing is his very own lovely lady! The one he is so desperately bored by and wants to “escape” if he only had the courage.
He’s cheating on her – and holy O. Henry – she’s cheating on him!
Instead of being angry, embarrassed, horrified or some understandable human emotion, they both have a great laugh about the whole situation.
That’s some serious artistic license. Why didn’t this one end with a third verse of real 1970s darkness like “The Night Chicago Died” or “Coward Of The County” and a murder-suicide, or at least one murder.
Not for nothing, but their relationship was so lousy, that the subject of pina coladas, champagne, yoga or walks in the rain never once came up? I hate these two people. They fucking deserve each other.
Are we supposed to believe they lived happily ever after?
Rupert Holmes and Jealousy
By the way, “Escape (The Pina Colada Song)” was the last #1 song of the 1970s if you happen to run a trivia night somewhere.
That era was the sweet spot for yacht rock. And while I don’t think of Rupert Holmes as yacht rock (consult my YR manifesto if you need clarity), Rupert’s protagonists do satisfy the yacht rock trope of cucked boyfriends and husbands.
Which leads us to Rupert Holmes’ other hit, “Him.” In it, a man discovers his partner may have a secret lover because the other dude leaves behind a different brand of cigarettes.
Yup, great detective work. There’s no explanation for another cigarette in your house other than your wife being an unfaithful slut.
Taken together, Rupert Holmes is an incredibly noteworthy two-hit wonder with pop hits built lyrically around jealousy and dysfunctional relationships.
The Music Saves The Day, Mostly
Go back and listen to “Escape” and pay attention to the chords. It won’t be hard, there’s only two of them. The sing song melody is as relentless as a never-ending bad relationship.
But “Escape” walked so “Him” could run. The production on “Him” is awesome. There are all kinds of chord changes, drum breaks, sections of instruments coming and going. And then the craziest solo you’ll hear in a while, consisting of a white guy “hoo hoo” scat solo into a high note at the end of the solo where there’s no possible way Holmes could have successfully pulled off singing live.
These two songs are aggressively cheerful despite the spiritual exhaustion and deception in the subject matter.
I gotta tip my cap to Rupert Holmes for pulling all of this off, getting the world to love “the Pina Colada Song” and getting me to love “Him.” Or maybe I should just give props to the wonderful weirdness of the 1970s and 1980s.

Comments