Basement Songs: Joe Jackson, “Home Town”

For me, the waning days of summer always bring to mind the city homecoming fair that took place at the end of every August in my hometown of North Olmsted, Ohio. The fair, a celebration of the city’s past and present, was held at the North Olmsted Park, located right around from my childhood house, and was a weekend-long affair that always began on the last Friday night in August and ran through late Sunday afternoon.

I can recall the mystery, allure and romanticism of that city fair from the eyes of a child. At night, when the traffic noises had quieted, you could hear the excitement of the fair through the open windows of my bedroom. The cranking of the carnival rides, kids screaming, cotton candy machines swirling, grills sizzling, and rock and roll bands playing from the gazebo. Man, I wanted to be there; I wanted to be grown up enough to wander through the crowd and absorb those noises and smells and to feel like a part of the community.

By sixth grade, I was deemed old enough to venture up to the park during homecoming, as long as I was with a group of friends. If we were a pack we couldn’t get into trouble, right? Actually, I hung out with a good bunch of kids, and the heightened feelings and butterflies we felt around girls were more exciting than any mischief we might get into. Even as an awkward kid who didn’t attract many girls, it was still a great feeling to have.

Something happened during the transition between ninth and 10th grade, though, and the fair was no longer exciting; rather, it had become a quaint symbol of complacency. In my arrogant teenage mind, I looked at the hundreds of folks who had grown up in North Olmsted (and still lived there), and thought, “I’m not going to be like them. I’m going to get out of here.” Instead of looking forward to the fair’s wondrous foods and prizes, I looked forward to pointless nights of cruising the Metropark valley in the back of some guy’s Escort while the radio blared acts like the Who, Lou Reed and Joe Jackson.

I was exposed to a lot of Jackson in the ’80s. Although he was past his commercial peak, the angry snarl and the thoughtful lyrics were something that appealed to me — in fact, a quick trip through my collection reveals that I own more Jackson albums than the Who or Lou Reed combined.

The homecoming fair also became something of a nuisance in high school; it became an obligation, in particular the homecoming parade that took place on Sunday morning. As a child, I watched with pride and fascination as my father, the band director, would lead the high school marching band down the main street to the park. By the time I was a member of that band, with my father still leading the way, pride turned to fear of screwing up, or suffering the mocking stares of people on the street — and by the time I was in college, I was never around for those fairs. My classes always began in the middle of August and I tried to find reason not to go home so early in the semester. That fair was a symbol of my childhood, and I would always look at it that way.

Something about having children causes us to reach back into their memories and relive some of those candy-colored moments of youth. Sure, there are always the bad times you try to suppress or laugh off, but my good memories tend to outnumber the bad. Obviously, some of my good memories are times spent at that park on ridiculously hot and humid afternoons and the cool, star-filled nights when you couldn’t walk ten feet without bumping into someone you knew, or who knew your parents, your brother, your sisters.

I wish I still lived in a town like that. The closest we have is the small cul-de-sac where many of the neighbors meet on the street each night, or the small school where Julie is the head of the PTA and they all know our kids. I guess that’s somewhat the same, but we don’t have a fair quite like the one in my hometown.

Joe Jackson wrote a song about hometowns for his 1986 record, Big World. In its original version, “Home Town” is a quick, perky number performed by a band that includes Jackson’s longtime bass player, Graham Maby. That original take was filled with the same sneer and vinegar that I loved about him. However, in 1999, he recorded a live album, Summer in the City , containing a new take on the song, one much more reflective and one that really captures the feeling of a man looking back on his life. Lines like:

Of all the stupid things I could have thought
This was the worst
I started to believe

That I was born at seventeen”

and:

“But we never leave the past behind
We just accumulate

So sometimes when the music stops

I seem to hear a distant sound

Of waves and seagulls

Football crowds and church bells

And I . . .
Wanna go back to my home town

Though I know it’ll never be the same”

These lines feel deeper than they did back in the ’80s, perhaps because Jackson’s new take digs deeper into the lyrics and the inherent sentimentality of the song. By just singing solo while playing the piano, Jackson takes us all back to our hometowns, even if for just a brief time.

The artist has gone on record as saying that the newer version is one he prefers to the mid-’80s rocker. I have to agree with him. Joe rerecorded “Home Town” for Two Rainy Nights, a live album released in early 2004. This version is just as wonderful as the previous (though I prefer Summer in the City as whole better).

I’m a mutt of a European background, just another white kid from the ‘burbs. I spent a great deal of my youth searching for my heritage. It took me moving away and starting a family of my own to realize that my heritage lays in the worn-out playground equipment and beaten ground of that city park around the corner from our house, where the baseball fields felt like an afterthought and there always seemed to be a blood drive at the community center or boy scouts camping in the open fields.

North Olmsted is where I’m from, it is my heritage, and it is my hometown.

Tags: , ,

  • I got into Jackson relatively late, but when I heard this song it struck a chord immediately. I still go back to the town where I grew up, but it definitely isn't the same.
  • Bob B
    Is it the city's that aren't the same, or rather is it us?
  • Bob B
    oops...cities that should be
  • Definitely both. I've driven past the house I grew up in (which my mom sold a few years ago), and it's been completely redone. Very surreal experience.
  • Malchus
    My in-laws still live in my hometown, so I am back there frequently. I, too, have driven by the house where I grew up. My parents sold it ten years ago, but it still feels like it's our house. Thus, seeing the changes the new owners made always makes me grit my teeth.

    But I think everything changes, the cities and the people.
  • Stacie
    Hey Scott,
    N.O. homecoming starts tonight! You discribed it to a tee! I still look forward to it and seeing all the parents and kids from the city there. We cant get out of there without a few goldfish that kids have won. We all look forward to going and buying those fresh cut fries.
    There is No Place like home!!!!!!
  • Malchus
    I remember winning one of those goldfish and being told it would die within a couple weeks. Thing lived for a couple YEARS! Man, I can smell those fries right now, with vinegar poured all over them. And after that, it's on to the funnel cake.
  • I was talking with Matt Berlyant from Big Takeover about Jackson's rearranging of his material just the other day, and how I think that JJ's one of the few artists whose songs can actually get more compelling in a re-working. I think this is the case with this version of Hometown. I like this version so much better. And I agree it does a much better job of bringing out the sentiment.

    Actually now that I think of it, this live album is heavy on Night and Day II material, and every version on here of one of those songs completely trumps the LP versions.
  • You either love Jackson's reworkings or you don't. For myself, his German Polka version of "Is She Really Going Out With Him" is just plain fun. Others expecting verbatim run-throughs would hate it.
  • Are you talking about the one from his Live 86 or whatever it is album where there's three different versions of ISRGOWH? I love that version. I actually like it just as well if not better than LP version. It's also a lot better than the elevator music sounding version on this Live in Portland album. I just think that acapella polka thing really brings out the strength of the arrangement and the melody better than the original studio version, which is just kinda thin and is really overshadowed by the rest of the songs on Look Sharp.
  • Malchus
    I also love the version of "It's Different For Girls" that is on the Live 86 album. It's superior in its arrangement and much more poignant. That's the thing about Jackson, so many of his songs are full of heart and it really comes out in his live performances.

    I guess I might as well piss off some people by saying that I prefer Jackson over Elvis Costello.
  • Seconded, and right now I prefer Graham Parker over both of them. But I also think that the acclaim Elvis Costellos has gotten over all of them is deserved.
  • Jaybug
    Me too bro. I only lived there for 8 of my 37 years...but it's still where I'm from.
    Can you believe that Scott. I only lived there 8 years and it seems like a lifetime. It was a lifetime. It kinda hurts just to think about the past like this. I miss my North Olmsted, but when I was there, I too, wanted to break out and take on the new world. And now that I think about the present and OUR new hometown...man I wouldn't change ANYTHING. It took all that too get where we are today. It's now up to us to make our kids memories of family, home and belonging as cherished as ours.
    Oops, I forgot to write about the song...uh, it was a good song...
    Hi Stacie, enjoy the fair.
    Oh yeah, Scott, did you ever get to play in a band at the fair?
    I played with Neil Stenger, Myke Grayshaw, Craig Dyson and Dave Riley in 'Rumors'. Maybe Sonny Mullins was even in the band.
  • Malchus
    Nope, I never got to play the fair, not even with the great Sonny Mullins.
  • I love this post and I feel much the same way about "Hometown", also being a major JJ fan (I'm the guy who wrote the 2-part Idiot's Guide on him that was on Jefito, but is sadly not on here). However, I have to point out that the version of "Hometown" on Big World does not feature Graham Maby. In fact, Big World is one of the very few JJ albums where Graham Maby doesn't make an appearance at all. A guy named Rick Ford was the bass player on that album and the subsequent tour. Another thing to note is that since Big World is technically a live album (it's a direct to 2-track recording with audience noise eliminated), he's never recorded it in a studio, at least to the best of my knowledge.
blog comments powered by Disqus